GPU Performance Showdown: M1 Ultra vs RTX 3080 Ti in Machine Learning

Create articles from any YouTube video or use our API to get YouTube transcriptions

or, create a free article to see how easy it is.

Introduction

In the ever-evolving landscape of computing technology, the performance of graphics processing units (GPUs) plays a crucial role, especially in machine learning applications. This article delves into a comparative analysis between two powerhouse GPUs: Apple's M1 Ultra with its integrated 48-core GPU and NVIDIA's RTX 3080 Ti discrete graphics card. We'll explore their capabilities, performance metrics, and implications for machine learning tasks.

The Contenders

Apple M1 Ultra

The M1 Ultra represents the pinnacle of Apple's silicon design, featuring:

48-core integrated GPU
Part of Apple's unified memory architecture
Built on advanced 5nm process technology

NVIDIA RTX 3080 Ti

NVIDIA's RTX 3080 Ti is a high-end discrete graphics card known for:

Dedicated GPU design
Advanced ray tracing capabilities
Large VRAM capacity

The Test Environment

To ensure a fair comparison, the following setup was used:

M1 Ultra System: Mac Studio running macOS
RTX 3080 Ti System: Intel Core i9 machine running Ubuntu in Windows Subsystem for Linux (WSL)

Both systems were configured with Miniconda and the necessary dependencies for the machine learning test.

The Benchmark: TensorFlow Machine Learning Test

The benchmark used for this comparison is a machine learning test developed by Thomas Capel, utilizing TensorFlow. This test is designed to stress the GPU and provide a realistic scenario for machine learning workloads.

Test Procedure

Clone the repository containing the test scripts
Set up the environment on both machines
Run the test using the time command to measure execution duration
Record GPU names for result tracking

Performance Results

RTX 3080 Ti Performance

The NVIDIA RTX 3080 Ti completed the test in:

First run: 5 minutes 59 seconds
Second run: 5 minutes 51 seconds

M1 Ultra Performance

The Apple M1 Ultra completed the test in:

First run: 14 minutes 59 seconds
Second run: 14 minutes 49 seconds

Analysis of Results

Speed Comparison

The RTX 3080 Ti outperformed the M1 Ultra by a significant margin:

The RTX 3080 Ti was approximately 2.5 times faster than the M1 Ultra
Consistent performance across multiple runs for both GPUs

Factors Influencing Performance

Several factors contribute to the performance difference:

Dedicated vs. Integrated GPU: The RTX 3080 Ti is a dedicated graphics card, while the M1 Ultra has an integrated GPU
Architecture Differences: NVIDIA's architecture is specifically optimized for machine learning tasks
Memory Bandwidth: Dedicated GPUs often have higher memory bandwidth
CUDA Optimization: Many machine learning frameworks are highly optimized for NVIDIA's CUDA platform

Power Consumption and Efficiency

M1 Ultra Power Draw

Approximately 117 watts during the test
Consistent power usage throughout the benchmark

RTX 3080 Ti Power Draw

Fluctuated between 300 and 500+ watts
Peak power draw exceeded 500 watts

Efficiency Considerations

While the M1 Ultra was slower in this specific test, it demonstrated significantly better power efficiency:

Lower overall power consumption
Potentially better performance per watt
Implications for data centers and large-scale deployments

Thermal Performance and Noise

M1 Ultra Thermal Behavior

Fans remained at a constant 1300 RPM
Minimal temperature increase
Unexpected cricket-like noise reported during heavy load

RTX 3080 Ti Thermal Behavior

Significant fan noise increase during the test
Higher overall system temperatures

GPU Utilization

M1 Ultra GPU Usage

Reached nearly 100% utilization during the test
Activity Monitor showed consistent high usage

RTX 3080 Ti GPU Usage

Presumed high utilization based on power draw and performance
Specific utilization data not provided in the test results

Implications for Machine Learning Practitioners

Choosing the Right Hardware

Task-Specific Requirements: Consider the nature of your machine learning workloads
Framework Compatibility: Ensure your chosen frameworks are optimized for your hardware
Budget Considerations: Weigh performance gains against hardware costs
Power and Cooling: Factor in infrastructure requirements for high-performance GPUs

M1 Ultra Advantages

Excellent for general-purpose computing and Apple ecosystem integration
Superior power efficiency
Quiet operation even under load

RTX 3080 Ti Advantages

Superior performance in machine learning tasks
Wide support across various ML frameworks
Potential for further optimization in pure Linux environments

Future Developments and Considerations

Apple Silicon Roadmap

Potential for improved machine learning performance in future iterations
Ongoing development of Metal and other Apple-specific ML frameworks

NVIDIA's Continued Innovation

Next-generation GPUs may further widen the performance gap
Advancements in CUDA and GPU-accelerated computing

The Role of Software Optimization

Importance of framework-specific optimizations
Potential for improved performance through software updates

Limitations of the Study

Single Benchmark Focus: Results may vary with different machine learning tasks
Operating System Differences: The RTX 3080 Ti was tested under WSL, which may impact performance
Limited Sample Size: More runs and varied conditions could provide more comprehensive data
Lack of PyTorch Testing: Current limitations in GPU support for PyTorch on Apple Silicon

Conclusion

The comparison between the M1 Ultra and the RTX 3080 Ti in this specific machine learning benchmark reveals a clear performance advantage for the dedicated NVIDIA GPU. However, it's crucial to consider the broader context:

Performance vs. Efficiency: The M1 Ultra offers significantly better power efficiency
Ecosystem Considerations: Each platform has its strengths in different computing scenarios
Future Potential: Both Apple and NVIDIA continue to innovate in GPU technology

For machine learning practitioners, the choice between these platforms should be based on specific workload requirements, power constraints, and ecosystem preferences. While the RTX 3080 Ti demonstrates superior raw performance in this test, the M1 Ultra's efficiency and integration within the Apple ecosystem may be preferable for certain use cases.

As the field of machine learning and GPU computing continues to evolve, we can expect further advancements from both Apple and NVIDIA, potentially shifting the performance landscape in the future.

Additional Resources

By staying informed about the latest developments in GPU technology and machine learning frameworks, practitioners can make informed decisions about their hardware choices and optimize their workflows for maximum efficiency and performance.

Article created from: https://youtu.be/k_rmHRKc0JM?si=-sVp-q3_msMcLGSX