Data Cleaning Framework for Aspiring Analysts: The CLEAN Method

The Importance of Data Cleaning for Aspiring Analysts

Data cleaning is a crucial skill for aspiring analysts. While many understand the technical fundamentals, truly standing out requires comprehending how data cleaning fits into day-to-day work. Hiring managers often test candidates on both the "how" and "why" of data cleaning processes. To excel, analysts need not only technical proficiency but also a robust framework for approaching any dataset across various industries.

The CLEAN Framework: A Comprehensive Approach

The CLEAN framework provides a structured method for data cleaning:

• Conceptualize
• Locate solvable issues
• Evaluate unsolvable issues
• Augment and improve the dataset
• Note and document

Let's explore each step in detail.

Conceptualize: Understanding the Dataset

Before diving into technical fixes, it's crucial to understand what the dataset represents. This step involves:

1. Identifying the grain, measures, and dimensions of the dataset
2. Determining critical vs. non-critical columns
3. Understanding the definitions of critical columns

Grain, Measures, and Dimensions

• Grain: What each row in the dataset represents
• Measures: Quantitative values requiring proper number formatting
• Dimensions: Qualitative values needing correct spelling, consolidation, and categorization

Critical vs. Non-Critical Columns

Identify which columns are essential for the analysis, typically requiring over 80% completeness or accuracy.

Column Definitions

Understand the meaning of each critical column, including:

• Date column definitions and relationships
• Price conversion rates and dates
• Product identification methods

Spend 30 minutes to an hour on this step, aiming to summarize the dataset concisely.

Locate Solvable Issues

Common solvable issues fall into three categories:

1. Formatting
2. Consistency
3. Duplicates

Formatting Issues

• Inconsistent number formats
• Inconsistent date formats
• Incorrect data types

Consistency Issues

• Spelling and spacing differences
• Categorization inconsistencies (e.g., USA vs. United States of America)

Duplicates

• Erroneously repeated rows that skew data

Use various methods to identify these issues:

• Visual inspection
• Pivot tables
• Group by functions
• Window functions

Focus on critical columns and prioritize making them usable for analysis. Remember, perfection isn't necessary; you can always refine the data later if needed.

Evaluate Unsolvable Issues

Unsolvable challenges typically fall into two categories:

1. Missing data
2. Nonsensical data

Missing Data

Blank or null values with unknown reasons for absence.

Nonsensical Data

Values that don't make logical sense, such as:

• Sales dates after refund dates
• Invalid account creation methods
• Non-existent country codes

To address these issues:

1. Benchmark the severity by calculating the percentage or magnitude of affected data
2. Determine the appropriate action based on the severity:
   • If >70% of a critical column is affected, consider the data unusable
   • If <10% is affected, leave as-is and caveat in the analysis
   • For issues in between, exercise judgment based on domain knowledge and analysis feasibility

Options for handling unsolvable issues:

• Leave data as-is and flag nonsensical values
• Impute missing values (e.g., using mean or external data sources)
• Exclude affected records from the analysis

Document your decisions and the severity of the issues addressed.

Augment and Improve the Dataset

Enhance your dataset by:

1. Performing calculations between existing columns
2. Adding information from separate datasets

Examples:

• Calculate shipping time, time to refund, etc.
• Add geographic details using country codes

Consider what additional information would benefit your analysis and how to obtain or derive it.

Note and Document

Documentation is crucial for demonstrating your skills and thought process. Create a change log that includes:

• Issues found
• Magnitude and severity of issues
• Resolution status and methods

This documentation helps explain your process to managers or stakeholders and solidifies your own understanding.

Applying the CLEAN Framework

To build your data cleaning intuition:

1. Apply the CLEAN framework to every new dataset you encounter
2. Practice regularly to improve speed and efficiency
3. Be prepared to explain your process in interviews or take-home tests

The Importance of Business Context

Understanding the business context is crucial when applying any analytical skill, including data cleaning. Let's explore how data cleaning fits into the day-to-day work of an analyst.

The Analytics Lifecycle

1. Stakeholder Meeting: Discuss business problems and questions
2. Requirements Gathering: Establish timelines, deliverables, and desired outputs
3. Data Preparation and Analysis: Gather and clean data, build analyses and visualizations
4. Communication of Findings: Present insights to stakeholders
5. Decision Making: Determine next steps (iterate or move forward)

Data cleaning primarily occurs during the data preparation stage but may be revisited throughout the analysis process.

Real-World Example: E-commerce Company Analysis

Let's apply the CLEAN framework to a hypothetical scenario:

You're a data analyst at an e-commerce company, tasked with preparing insights for a company-wide town hall. The leadership team wants a historic review of sales trends, including:

• Key sales trends over the last four years
• Monthly and yearly growth rates
• Trends in refund rates and delivery times

Applying the CLEAN Framework

Conceptualize

1. Identify grain, measures, and dimensions:

   • Grain: Each row represents a transaction
   • Measures: Sales amounts, refund amounts, delivery times
   • Dimensions: Dates, product information, customer demographics, marketing data

2. Determine critical columns:

   • Sales columns
   • Date columns
   • Refund information
   • Delivery time data

3. Understand column definitions:

   • Clarify meanings of different date columns (order date, ship date, delivery date, refund date)
   • Understand price columns (USD vs. local currency, conversion rates)
   • Verify product identification methods

Locate Solvable Issues

1. Formatting:

   • Standardize number formats for sales and refund amounts
   • Ensure consistent date formats across all date columns

2. Consistency:

   • Check for and consolidate variations in product names or categories
   • Standardize country names or codes

3. Duplicates:

   • Identify and remove any duplicate transaction records

Evaluate Unsolvable Issues

1. Missing Data:

   • Calculate percentage of missing values in critical columns
   • Decide on appropriate action based on severity (e.g., impute, exclude, or leave as-is)

2. Nonsensical Data:

   • Identify illogical date relationships (e.g., refund date before sale date)
   • Flag suspicious sales amounts or delivery times

Augment and Improve

1. Calculate new metrics:

   • Time to deliver (delivery date - ship date)
   • Time to refund (refund date - sale date)
   • Monthly and yearly growth rates

2. Add external data:

   • Incorporate regional information based on country codes
   • Add product category hierarchies if not already present

Note and Document

Create a change log documenting:

• Percentage of records affected by each issue
• Actions taken to resolve issues
• Rationale for decisions on unsolvable issues
• New calculations or data additions made

Best Practices for Data Cleaning

1. Preserve Raw Data: Always keep an untouched copy of the original dataset
2. Iterative Process: Be prepared to revisit data cleaning as you progress through analysis
3. Prioritize Critical Columns: Focus on making the most important data usable first
4. Document Everything: Keep detailed notes on all changes and decisions
5. Understand Limitations: Be aware of what the cleaned data can and cannot tell you
6. Communicate Clearly: Be prepared to explain your cleaning process to non-technical stakeholders

Common Pitfalls to Avoid

1. Over-cleaning: Spending too much time trying to achieve perfect data
2. Ignoring Business Context: Cleaning data without understanding its purpose in the analysis
3. Failing to Document: Not keeping track of changes made during the cleaning process
4. Overwriting Original Data: Always work on a copy, never the original dataset
5. Assuming Data Quality: Always verify and validate, even with supposedly "clean" datasets
6. Neglecting Unsolvable Issues: Failing to address or document problems that can't be fully resolved

Advanced Data Cleaning Techniques

As you become more proficient with the CLEAN framework, consider incorporating these advanced techniques:

1. Automated Data Profiling

Use tools or scripts to automatically generate data quality reports, identifying potential issues across large datasets quickly.

2. Machine Learning for Anomaly Detection

Implement machine learning algorithms to identify outliers or anomalies that may indicate data quality issues.

3. Fuzzy Matching

Use fuzzy matching algorithms to identify and consolidate similar but not identical text entries, particularly useful for product names or customer information.

4. Time Series Analysis for Data Validation

Apply time series techniques to validate data consistency over time and identify temporal anomalies.

5. Data Lineage Tracking

Implement systems to track the origin and transformations of data, making it easier to troubleshoot issues and understand data provenance.

Integrating Data Cleaning into the Analytics Workflow

To truly excel as an analyst, integrate data cleaning seamlessly into your overall analytics process:

1. Preliminary Data Assessment

Before beginning any analysis, conduct a quick data quality assessment using the CLEAN framework.

2. Continuous Monitoring

Implement ongoing data quality checks throughout your analysis to catch any issues that may arise.

3. Collaborative Cleaning

Work with domain experts and stakeholders to validate cleaning decisions and ensure business relevance.

4. Version Control

Use version control systems to track changes to your datasets and cleaning scripts over time.

5. Automated Testing

Develop automated tests to verify data quality and catch regressions in your cleaning process.

Conclusion

Mastering the CLEAN framework for data cleaning is essential for aspiring analysts. By systematically approaching data preparation, you'll build confidence in handling any dataset across various industries. Remember that data cleaning is an iterative process that requires both technical skills and business acumen.

As you apply this framework to your projects and real-world scenarios, you'll develop a keen intuition for data quality issues and efficient resolution strategies. This expertise will not only improve the quality of your analyses but also set you apart in interviews and on the job.

Continue to practice and refine your data cleaning skills, always keeping in mind the broader context of your analysis and the needs of your stakeholders. With time and experience, you'll become adept at quickly assessing and preparing data for meaningful insights that drive business decisions.

Article created from: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iYEw8L3Un4c