The Sunken Cost Fallacy of Protracted War: Analyzing the Ukraine-Russia Conflict

Recent Battlefield Developments

The Ukraine-Russia conflict continues to evolve, with notable changes occurring on multiple fronts. Let's examine some of the key developments:

Sumy Oblast

In the Sumy region, there has been a significant increase in the gray zone area, stretching from Noveneni to Basivia. This represents approximately a 6 km change in the gray zone. The Russian military has reportedly taken control of the locality of Basia in Sumy, though this information is still awaiting full confirmation.

Donetsk Front

Near Toretsk, there are reports of Russian gains to the north of the city. However, the exact situation remains unclear, with conflicting information from various sources.

Zaporizhzhia Front

In the Alexandropil area, Russian forces have reportedly advanced across a key road, potentially cutting off a main service route for Ukrainian forces.

Southern Front

To the west of Lobove, there is a confirmed Russian advancement of approximately 500 meters between Kamayanssky and Lobove. This area may be a potential focus for future Russian offensive operations.

Strategic Strikes and Their Impact

Overnight strikes have been reported from both sides, with civilian casualties tragically caught in the crossfire. One particularly noteworthy strike was against the Saransk optics systems facility in Russia, which is the country's only center for producing fiber optics. While some speculate this could impact Russia's ability to operate fiber optically controlled drones, it's important to adopt a wait-and-see approach to assess the true impact of such strikes.

Diplomatic Challenges and the "Impossible Diplomacy"

The diplomatic situation surrounding the conflict remains highly complex, with the positions of the involved parties far apart. This creates what can be termed "impossible diplomacy," where finding common ground for negotiations becomes increasingly difficult as the war progresses.

European Security Arrangements

U.S. Senator Marco Rubio has called for more concrete action from Europe regarding security arrangements for Ukraine. While European leaders hold numerous meetings, tangible results on the front lines are slow to materialize. Proposals for "boots on the ground" from some European leaders face significant hurdles, including the need for at least a ceasefire and U.S. backing.

U.S. Stance on Peace Negotiations

U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken has stated that the U.S. will know within weeks whether Russia is serious about pursuing peace with Ukraine. However, this raises the question of what happens if Putin simply says "no" to peace negotiations or ceasefire proposals.

The Sunken Cost Fallacy in Protracted War

The concept of the sunken cost fallacy plays a significant role in understanding the ongoing conflict. As both Ukraine and Russia have invested heavily in terms of lives, resources, and political capital, they become less willing to accept peace deals that don't seem to justify these losses.

Existential Nature of the Conflict

Both Ukrainian President Zelensky and Russian President Putin view this war as existential for the future of their respective states. The losses incurred through combat and demographic shifts will have long-lasting impacts on both countries.

Manpower Paradox

One puzzling aspect of the conflict is Ukraine's reluctance to lower its mobilization age from 25, despite ongoing manpower issues. This creates a paradox where Ukraine claims the war is existential while not taking all possible measures to address its troop shortages.

Assessing Battlefield Goals and Realistic Outcomes

When analyzing the conflict, it's crucial to assess whose goals are closer to being achieved and which outcomes are more realistic:

Russian Objectives

• Prevent Ukraine from joining NATO
• Maintain control over occupied territories (Donetsk, Luhansk, Zaporizhzhia, Kherson, and Crimea)
• Lift international sanctions

Ukrainian Objectives

• Secure NATO membership or equivalent security guarantees
• Receive sufficient military aid to liberate occupied territories
• Prosecute Russian leaders
• Obtain reparations from frozen Russian assets

Predictions for the Future of the Conflict

Based on the current situation and the war termination theory discussed earlier, several predictions can be made:

1. The conflict is likely to continue as a grinding war of attrition.
2. A clean end to the war or a lasting ceasefire is unlikely in the near term.
3. Russia may experience reduced global influence and increased reliance on China.
4. Ukraine faces the risk of demographic collapse, with population projections suggesting a potential decline to under 10 million by 2100.
5. Both sides may eventually look back and question when peace should have been made, as conditions deteriorate further.

Conclusion

The Ukraine-Russia conflict remains a complex and evolving situation with far-reaching consequences for both countries and the international community. As the war continues, the sunken cost fallacy may drive both sides to pursue increasingly costly strategies, potentially leading to further deterioration of the front lines and the overall power of both nations.

It's crucial for observers and analysts to approach the conflict with nuance, avoiding oversimplification of either side's motivations or capabilities. By maintaining a balanced perspective and considering the human element on all sides, we can better understand the dynamics at play and potentially work towards more effective solutions for peace and stability in the region.

Article created from: https://youtu.be/CXPnaSrw2ZQ?feature=shared