SSD vs HDD in Plex Media Servers - Analyzing Power Consumption and Performance

Introduction to NAS Systems and Media Storage Options

With the rising costs of electricity, many users are reconsidering their choices in home media servers, particularly when it comes to the type of storage used—Hard Disk Drives (HDDs) versus Solid State Drives (SSDs). This analysis dives deep into the performance metrics of both storage types within a NAS system, specifically the Synology DS 423+, during various media playback scenarios.

Understanding Power Consumption in NAS Systems

The primary concern for many when setting up a NAS for Plex Media Server is the power consumption, especially given the current energy prices. Our tests involved comparing a Synology DS 423+ populated with Toshiba 4TB HDDs against the same model equipped with Kingston DC 600M SSDs. The tests covered playback scenarios from native 1080p to dense 8K media files.

Power Efficiency During Media Playback

• Native Playback: Initial tests on native playback of various 1080p files showed that SSDs consume significantly less power than HDDs. For instance, while playing back media at different bit rates (from 3 Mbps to 100 Mbps), SSD setups used up to three times less power than their HDD counterparts.
• Transcoding Performance: When transcoding from higher resolutions down to lower ones (e.g., from 4K to 240p), SSD-equipped NAS systems showed a more modest reduction in power usage compared to native playback. However, the difference wasn't as pronounced as one might expect.

Evaluating System Performance and CPU Utilization

During these tests, we also monitored CPU utilization which is crucial for understanding how well a NAS can handle multiple tasks simultaneously. Both systems used an Intel J4125 CPU but showed no significant difference in CPU load between using SSDs or HDDs during most tests. This suggests that while SSDs are more power-efficient, they don't necessarily reduce CPU load significantly under typical usage scenarios.

Impact on Multimedia Handling

• Handling Dense Media: In scenarios involving very high-bitrate files (200 Mbps and above), SSDs began showing their strength. For example, an 8K video file at 160 Mbps saw about a 20-25 watt difference in favor of SSDs over HDDs due to faster data delivery which reduces overall system strain.
• Transcoding Dense Files: Transcoding dense files like those in 8K resolution demonstrated that while both drive types eventually complete tasks effectively, SSDs tend to maintain lower power consumption throughout the process.

Cost Considerations

Despite their benefits, SSDs still come at a higher price per terabyte compared to HDDS—a factor that can't be ignored when building or upgrading a NAS system. The price gap has narrowed over the years but remains significant enough to be a decisive factor for many users.

Conclusion on Choosing Between HDD and SSD for Plex Servers

For users with extensive libraries of high-resolution media or those who require frequent access to large files quickly and efficiently, investing in an SSD-equipped NAS could be worthwhile due to its lower power consumption and faster data processing capabilities. However, for general use where cost is a major consideration or where media isn't as dense or demanding, traditional hard drives may still hold sway.

This analysis underscores that while technology advancements have made SSDs more appealing for specific scenarios within Plex servers, traditional hard drives continue to offer value especially where budget constraints are prioritized over cutting-edge performance.

Article created from: https://youtu.be/2v4ciy1WJwM?si=a8mLjT0Ml-BRCSBa