Rental Car Companies and Electric Vehicles: A Bumpy Road Ahead

The Electric Vehicle Rental Experience: A Case Study

As electric vehicles (EVs) become more prevalent on our roads, rental car companies are starting to incorporate them into their fleets. However, this transition is not without its challenges. A recent experience with Thrifty Car Rental highlights some of the issues both customers and companies face when it comes to renting EVs.

The Rental Process

The journey began with booking a Polestar 2, an all-electric vehicle, from Thrifty in Melbourne for a three-day rental. The initial quoted price was approximately $215 AUD, which seemed like a good deal. However, upon receiving the final bill, the customer was charged $296 AUD, plus an additional $21.60 for charging the vehicle after its return.

This discrepancy between the quoted price and the final bill is concerning and raises questions about transparency in pricing. Rental car companies need to be clear about all potential charges upfront to avoid customer dissatisfaction.

The Charging Conundrum

One of the most significant issues highlighted in this experience was the charging requirements set by Thrifty. Customers are instructed to return the vehicle with a 90% charge. This requirement presents several problems:

1. Manufacturer Recommendations: Both Polestar and Tesla, the EV brands mentioned in Thrifty's fleet, recommend charging their vehicles to only 80% for regular use. Thrifty's 90% requirement goes against these guidelines.

2. Charging Time: Charging an EV from 80% to 90% or higher takes significantly longer than charging from a lower percentage to 80%. This is due to the charging curve of EV batteries, which slows down as the battery nears full capacity.

3. Practicality: For customers returning a vehicle, finding a fast-charging station near the rental location and waiting for the extra time to reach 90% is often impractical, especially for early morning flights or tight schedules.

4. Extra Charges: Failure to meet the 90% requirement results in additional charges, as experienced by the customer in this case.

These issues suggest that Thrifty's charging policy may not be well-thought-out or customer-friendly. A more reasonable requirement might be to return the vehicle at 80% charge, aligning with manufacturer recommendations and practical charging times.

Lack of Customer Education

Another critical issue highlighted in this experience is the lack of customer education provided by Thrifty regarding EV operation. For many customers, renting an EV might be their first experience with this type of vehicle. Yet, according to the account, Thrifty provided no instruction or guidance on:

• Location of charging cables
• How to charge the vehicle
• Different types of charging (home charging vs. fast charging)
• Basic EV operation

This lack of information can lead to confusion, frustration, and potentially dangerous situations if customers are unfamiliar with EV operation. Rental companies transitioning to EVs must invest in customer education to ensure a smooth and safe rental experience.

Operational Inefficiencies

The experience also revealed potential operational inefficiencies within Thrifty:

1. After-hours Returns: The customer had difficulty locating the after-hours return box, indicating poor signage or instructions for late-night returns.

2. Vehicle Location: Thrifty staff were unable to locate the returned vehicle for nearly 17 hours after it was dropped off, suggesting issues with their vehicle tracking system.

3. Charging Management: The long delay in locating and charging the returned vehicle implies that Thrifty may not have an efficient system for managing EV charging between rentals.

These inefficiencies could lead to vehicles being out of service for extended periods, reducing the company's ability to rent out its EV fleet effectively.

The Broader Implications for Rental Car Companies

The issues highlighted in this case study have broader implications for the car rental industry as it adapts to the growing EV market.

Fleet Management Challenges

Rental companies face unique challenges in managing an EV fleet:

1. Charging Infrastructure: Companies need to invest in charging infrastructure at their locations to ensure vehicles are ready for the next customer.

2. Maintenance and Training: Staff need to be trained in EV maintenance and operation to provide proper service and support to customers.

3. Turnover Time: The time required to charge EVs between rentals may be longer than refueling gas vehicles, potentially impacting vehicle availability.

Customer Experience and Education

Rental companies must prioritize customer education and support for EV rentals:

1. Pre-rental Information: Provide clear information about EV operation, charging, and any special requirements before the rental period begins.

2. In-person Orientation: Offer a brief orientation when customers pick up the vehicle, covering basic operation and charging procedures.

3. Support Resources: Provide easily accessible resources (e.g., apps, hotlines) for customers who need assistance during their rental.

Pricing and Transparency

The discrepancy between quoted and final prices in this case study highlights the need for transparent pricing:

1. Clear Fee Structure: All potential fees, including those related to charging, should be clearly communicated upfront.

2. Realistic Charging Requirements: Charging requirements should be practical and align with manufacturer recommendations.

3. Simplified Billing: Bills should be easy to understand, avoiding complex codes or unexplained charges.

The Future of EVs in Car Rental

Despite the challenges highlighted in this case study, the future of EVs in the car rental industry is promising. The positive driving experience reported with the Polestar 2 demonstrates the potential appeal of EVs to rental customers.

Benefits of EV Rentals

1. Environmental Impact: EVs produce zero direct emissions, aligning with growing environmental concerns.

2. Cost Savings: While initial investment may be higher, EVs can offer lower operational costs over time.

3. Customer Appeal: Many customers are curious about EVs and may choose to rent one to experience the technology before making a purchase.

4. Technological Showcase: Rental EVs can showcase the latest automotive technology, potentially attracting tech-savvy customers.

Necessary Improvements

For EV rentals to succeed, companies like Thrifty need to address several key areas:

1. Staff Training: Ensure all staff are knowledgeable about EVs and can provide accurate information to customers.

2. Infrastructure Investment: Develop robust charging infrastructure at rental locations.

3. Customer Education: Create comprehensive yet easy-to-understand materials to educate customers about EV operation.

4. Streamlined Processes: Develop efficient systems for managing EV charging, maintenance, and turnover between rentals.

5. Transparent Pricing: Implement clear, upfront pricing that accounts for the unique aspects of EV rentals.

Conclusion

The transition to electric vehicles in the car rental industry presents both opportunities and challenges. While EVs offer environmental benefits and appeal to many customers, rental companies must adapt their operations and customer service approaches to accommodate this new technology.

The experience with Thrifty highlights several areas where improvement is needed, including customer education, operational efficiency, and pricing transparency. By addressing these issues, rental car companies can smooth the path for widespread EV adoption in their fleets.

Ultimately, the success of EVs in the rental market will depend on companies' ability to provide a seamless, user-friendly experience that showcases the benefits of electric vehicles while minimizing potential frustrations. With the right approach, EV rentals could become a significant and positive part of the car rental landscape, contributing to the broader transition towards sustainable transportation.

As the automotive industry continues its shift towards electrification, it's crucial for all stakeholders - manufacturers, rental companies, and customers - to work together to overcome these initial hurdles. By doing so, we can create a future where renting an electric vehicle is just as easy, if not easier, than renting a traditional gas-powered car.

The road ahead may be challenging, but with proper planning, investment, and a customer-centric approach, the electric revolution in car rentals can become a reality, benefiting both the industry and the environment.

Article created from: https://youtu.be/65lFUVPQKzI?feature=shared