Mastering Intelligent Investing: Key Strategies from Benjamin Graham's Classic

Introduction to Intelligent Investing

Investing successfully doesn't require genius-level intelligence, insider information, or extraordinary luck. What it does demand is a solid intellectual framework for decision-making and the ability to control one's emotions. Benjamin Graham's seminal work, "The Intelligent Investor," provides exactly this - a time-tested approach to investing that has proven its worth over decades.

Graham's investment strategy has been one of the most successful in the past century. The impressive track records of Graham himself and his numerous disciples, including Warren Buffett - currently one of the wealthiest individuals globally - stand as testament to the effectiveness of his methods. Buffett himself has referred to "The Intelligent Investor" as "by far, the best book on investing ever written."

In this comprehensive guide, we'll explore the key takeaways from Graham's masterpiece, providing you with invaluable insights to enhance your investment strategy.

Understanding Mr. Market

One of Graham's most powerful concepts is the allegory of Mr. Market. Imagine you own a $1000 stake in a business. Every day, a person named Mr. Market comes to your door with an opinion on what your share is worth, offering to either buy your share or sell you an additional one at that price.

The catch? Mr. Market is bipolar and his valuations can be wildly inconsistent. For instance, in March 2000, he might value your share at $2600, only to drop his estimate to $500 a year later - despite the company's income increasing by 50% and profits by 20% during that period.

Graham's core principle here is that a stock isn't just a ticker symbol with a price tag - it represents ownership in a real business. Because Mr. Market isn't always rational, the underlying value of the business can differ significantly from the price he's willing to pay.

For the investor who can maintain composure, Mr. Market presents a golden opportunity. You're not obligated to trade with him; you can choose to sell when his offers are unreasonably high and buy when he presents bargains.

In today's digital age, Mr. Market visits us far more frequently than in Graham's time. Every time we check our phones - which for many of us is over 100 times a day - we're essentially getting a visit from Mr. Market. However, the frequency of these "visits" doesn't mean we need to trade any more often than investors did in the 1970s. If Mr. Market's offer doesn't meet your standards, it's perfectly fine to ignore him and go about your day.

The Defensive Investor's Strategy

Graham identifies two types of investors: defensive (or passive) and enterprising (or active). Most people, due to time constraints, are better suited to the defensive strategy.

Portfolio Allocation

A defensive investor should create a portfolio with a mix of bonds and stocks. A common allocation is 50% stocks and 50% bonds, though this can vary based on individual circumstances and the current yield difference between stocks and bonds.

It's important to rebalance this allocation once or twice annually. If stocks suddenly make up 60% of your portfolio compared to 40% in bonds, sell some stocks and buy bonds to restore the 50/50 balance.

Dollar-Cost Averaging

Invest a fixed amount of capital at regular intervals, such as right after receiving your salary. This strategy, known as dollar-cost averaging, ensures a fair average price for stocks and bonds over time and prevents concentration of buying at inopportune moments.

Stock Selection Criteria

For the stock component of the portfolio, Graham recommends the following criteria:

1. Diversification: Invest in 10 to 30 companies, ensuring you're not overexposed to a single industry.
2. Company Size: Focus on large companies, defined by Graham as those generating more than $700 million in yearly sales (adjusted for inflation).
3. Financial Conservatism: Look for companies with a "current ratio" of at least 200%, meaning current assets are at least twice as large as current liabilities.
4. Dividend History: Choose companies that have paid dividends for at least the last 20 years.
5. Earnings Stability: Avoid companies with earnings deficits in the last ten years.
6. Earnings Growth: Seek companies with at least 33% growth in earnings over the last ten years (about 2.9% annually).
7. Asset Valuation: The stock price should not exceed 1.5 times the company's net asset value (assets minus liabilities).
8. Earnings Valuation: The price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio should not be higher than 15 when using the last 12-month earnings.

Index Fund Alternative

An alternative for defensive investors is to invest in an index fund, which by definition will yield returns similar to the market average. If you're content with average market returns, this approach, combined with the understanding of Mr. Market's behavior, may be sufficient for your investment strategy.

The Enterprising Investor's Approach

For those seeking to beat the market, the path of the enterprising investor beckons. However, this approach is far more demanding than it might initially appear.

Challenges of Active Investing

Beating the market requires patience, discipline, a willingness to learn, and a significant time investment. Many investors, both professional and private, struggle with this approach. It's surprisingly easy to fall victim to Mr. Market's price quotations, as evidenced by statements made by chief investment strategists during the dot-com bubble:

"It's a new world order.... We see people discard all the right companies, with all the right people, with the right visions, because their stock price is too high. That's the worst mistake an investor can make."

"Is the stock market riskier today than two years ago simply because the prices are higher? The answer is no!"

These statements, which turned out to be costly for investors, highlight the importance of maintaining a rational perspective.

Focus on Price

For the enterprising investor, price is crucial. The market tends to overvalue companies that have been growing rapidly or are considered glamorous for other reasons. Conversely, it often undervalues those with unsatisfactory development.

Graham advises avoiding "growth stocks" as much as possible. Why? Because the investment decision is based more on future earnings, which are less reliable than current valuations.

Value Investing Opportunities

If you can find a company valued lower than its net working capital (current assets minus total liabilities), you're essentially getting all fixed assets (buildings, machinery, goodwill, etc.) for free. Such opportunities were highly profitable during Graham's investment career, though they're rarer today except during severe bear markets.

Looser Criteria for Stock Selection

Graham suggests an additional method for enterprising investors, with criteria similar to those for defensive investors but with looser constraints:

1. No strict limit on company size
2. More flexible diversification requirements
3. In-depth analysis of annual financial reports

The Margin of Safety Principle

One risk that no amount of careful consideration can eliminate is the risk of being wrong. However, you can minimize this risk by insisting on a "margin of safety" for every investment.

Defining Margin of Safety

The margin of safety is the difference between a company's price and its calculated value. Graham suggests looking for companies priced at no more than two-thirds of their calculated value.

Valuation Formula

Graham provides a formula to estimate a company's value:

Value = current (normal) earnings x 8.5 + 2 x expected annual growth rate

The growth rate should reflect the expected yearly growth of earnings for the next 7 to 10 years.

Practical Application

Let's apply this formula to the three largest companies in the S&P 500 as of September 2018:

1. Apple
2. Amazon
3. Microsoft

By using the formula in reverse, we can determine the growth rate implied by current stock prices. For instance, Amazon's stock price might imply an expected growth rate of 74% per year, while Apple's might imply only 5.8%. This discrepancy raises questions about the rationality of current market valuations.

Risk and Reward: A New Perspective

Graham challenges the academic theory that risk and reward are always directly correlated. Instead, he argues that return is a function of the time and effort an investor puts into finding undervalued assets.

The Fallacy of High Risk, High Reward

Consider this analogy: You're offered $10,000 to play Russian Roulette with one bullet, or $100,000 to play with two bullets. The academic view would say the higher reward justifies the higher risk. But investing doesn't have to work this way.

Value Investing and Risk Reduction

When you buy a company at 60 cents on the dollar, you have a great potential reward with low risk. If you find another company you can buy at 40 cents on the dollar, you have an even better reward potential with even lower risk.

This principle challenges the notion that higher potential returns must come with higher risk. In value investing, the opposite can often be true.

Practical Application of Graham's Principles

Now that we've covered the key takeaways from "The Intelligent Investor," let's discuss how to apply these principles in today's market.

Emotional Discipline

Perhaps the most crucial aspect of Graham's teaching is the importance of emotional discipline. In an age of 24/7 financial news and constant market updates, it's more important than ever to maintain a level head.

Tip: Limit your exposure to financial news and market updates. Set specific times to check your portfolio, perhaps weekly or monthly, rather than constantly throughout the day.

Value Over Growth

Graham's preference for value over growth stocks remains relevant. While growth stocks can provide exciting returns, they often come with higher risk and volatility.

Tip: Look for companies with strong fundamentals trading at reasonable prices. Use metrics like the price-to-earnings ratio and price-to-book ratio to identify potentially undervalued stocks.

Diversification

Diversification remains a cornerstone of intelligent investing. However, in today's global economy, diversification can extend beyond just stocks and bonds.

Tip: Consider diversifying across different asset classes, including real estate investment trusts (REITs), commodities, and international markets.

The Power of Compounding

While not explicitly discussed in our summary, the power of compounding is implicit in Graham's long-term approach to investing.

Tip: Start investing early and reinvest dividends. Even small amounts can grow significantly over time thanks to compound interest.

Continuous Learning

Graham emphasized the importance of thorough research and continuous learning for the enterprising investor.

Tip: Stay informed about the companies you invest in. Read annual reports, follow industry trends, and consider taking courses on financial analysis.

Modern Tools for the Intelligent Investor

While Graham's principles remain timeless, modern investors have access to tools and resources that weren't available in his time.

Online Brokers and Robo-Advisors

Online brokers have made it easier than ever for individual investors to buy and sell securities. Robo-advisors can even automate much of the investment process, including portfolio rebalancing.

Tip: Choose a broker or robo-advisor that aligns with your investment style. Some cater more to active traders, while others are better for long-term, passive investors.

Financial Ratios and Screeners

Many websites and apps provide easy access to financial ratios and stock screeners, making it easier to apply Graham's criteria for stock selection.

Tip: Use stock screeners to filter for companies that meet Graham's criteria, such as low P/E ratios, consistent dividend payments, and strong balance sheets.

Index Funds and ETFs

Index funds and Exchange-Traded Funds (ETFs) provide an easy way for investors to achieve diversification and market-average returns.

Tip: Consider low-cost index funds or ETFs as the core of your portfolio, especially if you're a defensive investor.

Adapting Graham's Principles to Different Market Conditions

While Graham's principles are timeless, their application may vary depending on market conditions.

Bull Markets

During extended bull markets, it can be challenging to find stocks that meet Graham's strict value criteria.

Tip: In such times, focus on maintaining your asset allocation and avoiding the temptation to chase overvalued "hot" stocks.

Bear Markets

Bear markets often present opportunities for value investors, as stock prices may fall below intrinsic values.

Tip: Use market downturns as opportunities to buy quality companies at discounted prices, but be prepared for the possibility of further declines.

Low Interest Rate Environments

In periods of low interest rates, the bond portion of a portfolio may provide lower returns than historically normal.

Tip: Consider other income-generating investments, such as dividend-paying stocks or real estate investment trusts (REITs), but be aware of the additional risks these may carry.

The Psychological Aspect of Investing

Graham understood that successful investing is as much about psychology as it is about numbers.

Overcoming Behavioral Biases

Investors often fall prey to behavioral biases such as herd mentality, confirmation bias, and loss aversion.

Tip: Educate yourself about common behavioral biases in investing. Keeping a trading journal can help you identify and overcome your own biases.

Patience and Long-Term Thinking

Graham's approach requires patience and a long-term perspective, which can be challenging in a world of instant gratification.

Tip: Set long-term financial goals and regularly remind yourself of these goals to avoid being swayed by short-term market movements.

Conclusion: The Enduring Relevance of Graham's Wisdom

Benjamin Graham's "The Intelligent Investor" continues to offer valuable insights for modern investors. Its core principles - understanding market psychology, focusing on intrinsic value, maintaining a margin of safety, and keeping emotions in check - are as relevant today as they were when the book was first published.

While the specific numbers and ratios Graham used may need adjustment for today's market conditions, the underlying philosophy remains sound. Whether you choose to be a defensive investor focusing on index funds and a balanced portfolio, or an enterprising investor seeking undervalued opportunities, Graham's teachings provide a solid foundation for your investment journey.

Remember, successful investing is not about chasing the highest returns or timing the market perfectly. It's about making informed decisions based on thorough analysis, maintaining emotional discipline, and staying committed to your long-term financial goals.

As you apply these principles to your own investing, always keep in mind Graham's most important lesson: the investor's chief problem - and even his worst enemy - is likely to be himself. By understanding and controlling your own behavior, you'll be well on your way to becoming a truly intelligent investor.

Article created from: https://youtu.be/npoyc_X5zO8?si=OcUhNTWafn3BEML4