Egypt's Decade-Long Battle Against ISIS in the Sinai Peninsula

The Hidden War in Egypt's Sinai Peninsula

For over a decade, Egypt has been engaged in a fierce battle against ISIS militants in the Sinai Peninsula. This prolonged conflict, largely overlooked by Western media, has had significant implications for regional stability and global trade. The Sinai Peninsula, often referred to as the bridge between continents, connects Africa, Asia, and the Middle East. Its strategic importance cannot be overstated, as it forms the eastern half of the vital Suez Canal, through which approximately 15% of global trade passes annually.

The Rise of Insurgency in Sinai

The roots of the insurgency can be traced back to 2011 when extremist groups took advantage of the political instability following the Arab Spring revolution. These militants, exploiting the region's rugged terrain and lack of governance, launched deadly attacks and eventually controlled about a third of the villages in the peninsula.

The situation was exacerbated by the fall of Libya in 2011, which led to an influx of heavy weapons into Egypt. In the years leading up to Egypt's military intervention, the insurgency had:

• Sabotaged 15 oil pipelines
• Frequently targeted infrastructure critical to the Suez Canal
• Shut down the Arab gas pipeline, costing nearby Jordan $2 billion annually

Operation Eagle: Egypt's Initial Response

In August 2011, Egypt launched Operation Eagle, deploying 2,500 troops, armored vehicles, special forces brigades, main battle tanks, and attack helicopters to the Sinai Peninsula. The operation focused on three key locations:

1. Arish
2. Rafah (in Egypt)
3. Sheikh Zuweid

The Egyptian military's initial goals were to:

• Protect the Suez Canal
• Eliminate violent extremists
• Enhance border security and prevent smuggling
• Protect Egyptian citizens and improve their quality of life

Challenges Faced by Egyptian Forces

The Egyptian military faced several challenges in their counterinsurgency efforts:

1. Complex terrain: The Sinai Peninsula's diverse landscape, ranging from farmlands and deserts to mountains and residential cities, made military operations difficult.

2. Legal restrictions: Due to the 1979 Egypt-Israel peace treaty, Egypt had to obtain permission from Israel and the Multinational Force and Observers (MFO) before deploying troops to the Sinai.

3. Accidental engagements: The confusion between various factions led to incidents of friendly fire between Egyptian and Israeli forces.

4. Evolving insurgent tactics: Despite initial successes, militants continued to harass both Egyptian and Israeli forces on both sides of the border.

International Support and Political Changes

The United States provided significant support to Egypt's counterinsurgency efforts, including:

• Access to classified intelligence assets
• Updated satellite imagery
• Drone reconnaissance
• Cell phone intercepts

The U.S. has provided $1.3 billion in military aid to Egypt annually since the late 1970s. However, training missions were temporarily halted due to Egypt's political crisis following the Arab Spring.

The Impact of the Arab Spring

The 2011 Arab Spring revolution played a crucial role in the rise of the Sinai insurgency. The overthrow of President Mubarak's 30-year authoritarian rule plunged the country into chaos, creating an opportunity for extremist groups to exploit.

Escalation of Violence and Egyptian Military Response

Despite initial efforts, the militants grew stronger and carried out more brazen attacks. A significant turning point came in August 2012 when armed insurgents attacked a base in Rafah, killing 16 Egyptian soldiers and briefly penetrating Israeli territory.

In response, Egypt launched Operation Sinai in late 2012, committing an additional 8,000 troops to the battle. The operation aimed to:

• Destroy ISIS smuggling tunnels
• Shut down the illegal arms trade
• Deploy advanced military hardware, including F-16 and Mirage 2000 fighter jets

By 2018, the Egyptian Defense Forces had deployed 42,000 troops across 88 battalions to fight against ISIS. The military also engaged in widespread destruction of buildings and farmland believed to be assisting ISIS operations.

Understanding the Insurgents

To effectively combat the insurgency, it was crucial for Egyptian forces to understand the motivations and grievances of the local population, particularly the Bedouin tribes.

The Bedouin Factor

The Sinai Peninsula is home to approximately 200,000 Bedouin people who have a long history of living in the harsh landscape. These communities have faced discrimination and neglect from the Egyptian government, including:

• Being barred from joining the Egyptian army or police
• Difficulty finding jobs in the tourism sector
• Forced relocation from prime real estate areas

These grievances led some Bedouins to cooperate with militant groups, although most did not support their ideology.

ISIS in Sinai

The largest faction of militants in the Sinai eventually pledged allegiance to ISIS, forming the Sinai Islamic State. This group established ties with militants based in Libya and engaged in conflicts with other factions, such as Hamas in Gaza.

Egypt's Evolving Strategy

As the conflict progressed, the Egyptian military recognized the need to adapt its approach. Key changes included:

1. Restructuring forces to a more merit-based system
2. Increasing troop deployments and expanding military operations
3. Enhancing intelligence gathering and sharing with Israel
4. Implementing a naval blockade to cut off supply routes
5. Engaging with local Bedouin tribes

Cooperation with Israel

Despite public denials, Egypt reportedly allowed the Israeli Air Force to conduct covert airstrikes against ISIS targets in the Sinai Peninsula. This secret alliance proved effective in weakening the insurgents' capabilities.

Cutting Off Supply Lines

By 2018, Egypt's general intelligence service had become more proficient at identifying and disrupting the primary routes used to smuggle heavy weapons from Libya. The Egyptian Navy's blockade of sea routes, combined with efforts to shut down tunnel networks and desert crossings, severely impacted ISIS's supply lines.

The Final Push: Engaging Local Tribes and Economic Development

Two key strategies proved instrumental in turning the tide against ISIS in Sinai:

1. Alliance with the Union of Sinai Tribes
2. Economic development initiatives

The Union of Sinai Tribes

Egypt invested in building an alliance with the Union of Sinai Tribes, a group of Bedouin tribal leaders interested in fighting against ISIS. This approach allowed Bedouin villages to safeguard their own communities from a common enemy while refusing to harbor ISIS fighters.

The strategy mirrored successful counterinsurgency programs used by the United States in Iraq, such as the Sons of Iraq initiative. By working with local forces and building indigenous security capabilities, Egypt was able to create a more effective response to the insurgency.

Economic Development

President Sisi pledged over 700 billion Egyptian pounds (approximately $45 billion USD) for economic and infrastructure development in the Sinai Peninsula over an 8-year period. This initiative aimed to address the poverty and lack of opportunities that had made the region susceptible to insurgency.

The development plan included:

• New roads
• Tunnels
• Agricultural land
• Power stations

While the full implementation of this plan remains uncertain due to Egypt's ongoing economic challenges, it represents a step towards bringing the neglected Peninsula onto a more equal footing with the Egyptian mainland.

The Final Battle: Eliminating ISIS Leadership

The culmination of Egypt's counterinsurgency efforts came with the hunt for Salim Al-Hamadeen, one of the oldest members of ISIS Sinai and Egypt's most wanted man. Egyptian Special Forces, specifically their elite Unit 777 counterterrorism task force, teamed up with Bedouin militias from the Union of Sinai Tribes to track him down.

On March 23, 2021, the joint forces located Al-Hamadeen near Rafah, close to the Israeli border. A massive firefight ensued, resulting in the death of the ISIS leader. This operation demonstrated the effectiveness of Egypt's evolved strategy, combining elite military units with local tribal knowledge.

The Aftermath and Future Prospects

On January 25, 2023, President Sisi declared the counterterror operation in the Sinai Peninsula officially ended. While scattered attacks continue, the intensity and frequency of insurgent activities have significantly decreased.

In March 2024, ISIS itself acknowledged the defeat of its Sinai branch, declaring it inactive. This admission signals a major victory for Egypt's long-running counterinsurgency campaign.

However, several challenges remain:

1. Maintaining security gains: Egypt must remain vigilant to prevent a resurgence of militant activity.
2. Implementing economic development: The success of the pledged infrastructure and development projects will be crucial in addressing the root causes of instability in the region.
3. Balancing security with human rights: Egypt faces ongoing criticism for its heavy-handed approach to counterinsurgency, including the destruction of civilian property and forced relocations.
4. Regional cooperation: Continued collaboration with Israel and other neighboring countries will be essential in preventing future security threats.

Lessons Learned

Egypt's decade-long battle against ISIS in the Sinai Peninsula offers several valuable lessons for counterinsurgency operations:

1. Adaptability is key: Egypt's willingness to evolve its strategy from brute force to a more nuanced approach involving local tribes proved crucial.
2. Local engagement matters: Building alliances with indigenous populations can provide invaluable intelligence and support.
3. Economic development is a powerful tool: Addressing the root causes of instability through infrastructure and economic initiatives can complement military efforts.
4. Intelligence sharing and international cooperation can be game-changers: Egypt's covert collaboration with Israel and support from the United States played a significant role in the campaign's success.
5. Long-term commitment is necessary: Defeating a well-entrenched insurgency requires sustained effort and resources over many years.

Conclusion

Egypt's struggle against ISIS in the Sinai Peninsula demonstrates the complexities of modern counterinsurgency operations. From the initial deployment of troops in Operation Eagle to the final elimination of key ISIS leadership, the Egyptian military's approach evolved significantly.

By combining military force with local engagement, economic development, and international cooperation, Egypt was able to significantly weaken ISIS's presence in this strategically vital region. However, the long-term success of these efforts will depend on the government's ability to address the underlying socio-economic issues that fueled the insurgency in the first place.

As the world continues to grapple with the threat of extremist groups, the lessons learned from Egypt's Sinai campaign offer valuable insights for future counterinsurgency efforts. The importance of adaptability, local engagement, and a holistic approach combining security measures with economic development cannot be overstated in the ongoing global fight against terrorism.

Article created from: https://youtu.be/yEy8tAweqi0?feature=shared