Shifting Tides of Xenophobia in America from the 19th to 20th Century

The Roots of Xenophobia in 19th Century America

In the early 1800s, America was a hotbed of anti-Catholic sentiment, primarily targeting immigrants from Germany and Ireland. These groups faced severe hostility based on their religious beliefs, reflecting a broader pattern of xenophobia that demonized foreigners by attributing dangerous or inferior traits to them. This form of discrimination was not limited to religion but extended to national origin, class, gender, sexual orientation, and predominantly race.

The Shift Towards Chinese Immigrants

By the late 19th century, the focus of American xenophobia shifted towards Chinese immigrants. Unlike European immigrants who could eventually gain naturalized citizenship and thereby political power, Chinese immigrants were barred from these opportunities. The Naturalization Act of 1790 restricted citizenship to free white persons, a barrier that was solidified by the Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882. This legislation explicitly prevented Chinese individuals from becoming naturalized citizens, effectively relegating them to second-class status alongside Native Americans and African-Americans.

Political Power and Racial Hierarchies

The ability for white European immigrants to ascend politically through naturalization played a crucial role in reducing xenophobic attitudes towards them. As these groups gained voting rights and political representation, they could influence policies that previously fueled widespread discrimination against them. In contrast, Chinese immigrants remained powerless under existing laws that underscored their perceived racial differences.

The Rise of Eugenics in Early 20th Century America

By the 1920s, even white immigrants from Eastern Europe were scrutinized under new racial prejudices. These groups were often deemed not 'the right kind of white'—a reference specifically to non-Anglo-Saxon Protestants. This period marked a significant intersection between immigration policies and eugenics—a form of scientific racism that categorized humans based on supposed racial hierarchies.

Intellectual Foundations of Anti-Immigration Movements

The anti-immigration movements during this era were heavily influenced by eugenics. Proponents believed that controlling immigrant populations would preserve certain desirable racial characteristics within American society. This pseudoscientific approach provided an intellectual veneer to justify extensive immigration restrictions during this period.

Conclusion

The history of xenophobia in America reveals a pattern where economic concerns are often intertwined with racial prejudices. From Irish and German Catholics in the 19th century to Chinese and Eastern European immigrants in the early 20th century, these shifts reflect broader socio-political dynamics influenced by race-based ideologies like eugenics. Understanding this history is crucial for addressing contemporary issues around immigration and racial discrimination.

Article created from: https://youtu.be/CS24yJrkGp8