Puerto Rico's Financial Crisis: Insights from Former Governor Alejandro García Padilla

Introduction

Puerto Rico has faced severe economic challenges in recent years, culminating in a debt crisis and the implementation of a fiscal oversight board. To gain insight into the factors that led to this situation and potential paths forward, we spoke with former Governor Alejandro García Padilla, who led the island from 2013 to 2017 during some of its most turbulent financial times.

García Padilla's Path to the Governorship

García Padilla did not always envision himself becoming governor, though he grew up in an environment that valued public service. His grandfather had been involved in founding the Popular Democratic Party with Luis Muñoz Marín. García Padilla recalls politicians of that era often leaving office with less wealth than when they entered, as they were focused on service rather than personal enrichment.

His own path to leadership positions was somewhat unexpected:

• In 2004, he substituted for someone on a radio program for a week. When that person resigned, García Padilla was made the permanent host.
• When Aníbal Acevedo Vilá won the 2004 gubernatorial election, he appointed García Padilla as Secretary of Consumer Affairs.
• In 2008, García Padilla ran for and won a Senate seat, receiving more votes than candidates from the opposing party despite overall losses for his party that year.

Though he initially tried to maintain a low profile in the Senate, declining leadership positions, García Padilla found that some of his more progressive policy proposals actually increased his popularity. These included:

• Advocating for a value-added tax (IVA) system
• Discussing decriminalization of drugs
• Supporting marriage equality (then called civil unions)

Eventually, party members began to see him as a potential gubernatorial candidate, despite his efforts to avoid that trajectory.

Taking Office Amid Financial Crisis

When García Padilla assumed the governorship in 2013, Puerto Rico was already in dire financial straits:

• Government revenues were around $8 billion annually
• Government expenses were about $11 billion annually
• This resulted in a $3.3 billion annual deficit
• Previous administrations had been borrowing to cover this gap, eventually borrowing to pay off other loans

The pension system was also severely underfunded:

• For every $100 paid out in pensions, only $7 was being deposited into the system

García Padilla's administration had to take drastic measures:

• Government expenses were cut from $11 billion to $7.8 billion
• Revenues were increased to over $8 billion
• This allowed for a slight increase in spending, but still did not cover debt service payments

The IVA Proposal and Its Opposition

One of García Padilla's key proposals to address the fiscal crisis was implementing a value-added tax (IVA) system to replace the existing sales tax and income tax. He argues this would have several benefits:

• It's based on consumption rather than income, so those who spend more pay more
• It's self-enforcing, as businesses have an incentive to report transactions
• It would have eliminated income tax withholdings, effectively giving workers a raise
• Many goods and services would have been exempt, including education, healthcare, and utilities

However, the proposal faced significant opposition:

• Members of García Padilla's own party, including Manuel Natal and Carmen Yulín Cruz, opposed it
• The opposing party also rejected the plan
• Some economists who had previously supported a VAT system changed their position

Ultimately, without enough votes to pass the IVA, the administration had to increase the existing sales tax (IVU) to 11.5% instead.

The Path to PROMESA and Debt Restructuring

As the fiscal situation worsened, García Padilla's administration attempted to negotiate with creditors to restructure Puerto Rico's debt. However:

• Creditors were unwilling to accept proposed terms
• They filed an injunction in federal court to freeze Puerto Rico's bank accounts

This action actually accelerated the passage of PROMESA (Puerto Rico Oversight, Management, and Economic Stability Act) by the U.S. Congress. García Padilla describes a pivotal moment:

• He was in Washington D.C. meeting with Nancy Pelosi
• Paul Ryan, then Speaker of the House, called to ask if García Padilla supported PROMESA
• García Padilla responded that he had no real choice, comparing it to being robbed at gunpoint

PROMESA passed, establishing the fiscal oversight board but also providing Puerto Rico with protection from lawsuits and account seizures.

Reflections on Governance and Financial Management

García Padilla offered several insights on governing during a financial crisis:

Prioritizing Spending

• Like household finances, government always has more needs than resources
• The governor must establish priorities
• Some expenses, like payroll, are already fixed when a new administration takes office
• Decisions often come down to choosing between essential services and debt payments

The Importance of Financial Education

García Padilla expressed regret at not pushing harder for financial education in public schools. He believes:

• Basic financial literacy is crucial for individuals and the overall economy
• Practical skills like basic home repairs (previously taught in "industrial arts" classes) can also have financial benefits

The Role of Status in Puerto Rico's Economy

While acknowledging the importance of Puerto Rico's political status debate, García Padilla cautions against seeing it as a panacea for economic problems:

• Under the current Commonwealth status, Puerto Rico's economy grew rapidly in the 1980s
• The elimination of Section 936 tax incentives (at the request of pro-statehood politicians) had a major negative impact
• Issues like crime rates are not directly tied to political status
• A Government Accountability Office report indicated statehood would require at least $2.2 billion in additional taxes annually

Government as a Reflection of Society

García Padilla emphasized that in a democracy, the government tends to mirror the broader society:

• The same diversity of people and viewpoints found in society at large exists in government
• This is true at both the Puerto Rico and U.S. federal levels
• While corruption exists, it's important not to assume all politicians or public servants are corrupt

Conclusion

Alejandro García Padilla's tenure as governor of Puerto Rico came during one of the most challenging financial periods in the island's history. His insights provide valuable context for understanding the complex factors that led to the debt crisis and the difficult decisions faced by policymakers.

Key takeaways include:

• The long-term impact of eliminating Section 936 tax incentives
• The potential benefits of a value-added tax system and the political challenges of implementing it
• The delicate balance between providing essential services and meeting debt obligations
• The importance of financial education for long-term economic stability
• The need to look beyond political status debates to address fundamental economic issues

As Puerto Rico continues to navigate its financial challenges, the lessons and perspectives shared by García Padilla offer important considerations for policymakers, citizens, and anyone seeking to understand the complexities of managing an economy in crisis.

Article created from: https://youtu.be/gC35gQGfiBY?si=uZ3JkQAC1iiYjq8g