The Power of Owner's Earnings: A Key Metric for Value Investors

Understanding Owner's Earnings

Owner's earnings is a financial metric popularized by Warren Buffett that aims to capture the true economic profitability of a business. It's a crucial tool for value investors when analyzing companies and determining their intrinsic value. In this article, we'll explore what owner's earnings is, how to calculate it, and why it's so important for investment analysis.

What is Owner's Earnings?

Owner's earnings represents the amount of cash that could theoretically be paid out to shareholders without impacting a company's competitive position or growth prospects. It's meant to show the real cash flow available to owners after accounting for both maintenance capital expenditures and growth investments.

Buffett described owner's earnings as:

"The cash that the business generates, less any reinvestment necessary to maintain the business's competitive position and unit volume."

In other words, it's the cash flow that could be extracted from a business without harming its long-term prospects.

How to Calculate Owner's Earnings

The basic formula for owner's earnings is:

Owner's Earnings = Net Income + Depreciation & Amortization + Other Non-Cash Charges - Maintenance Capital Expenditures

Let's break this down:

1. Start with net income as reported
2. Add back non-cash expenses like depreciation and amortization
3. Add other non-cash charges (stock-based compensation, deferred taxes, etc.)
4. Subtract maintenance capital expenditures needed to maintain current operations

The trickiest part is usually estimating maintenance capex. This requires judgment to separate growth capex from maintenance capex. Some analysts use depreciation as a proxy, but this can be inaccurate.

Why Owner's Earnings Matters

Owner's earnings provides several key benefits for investors:

1. More accurate than GAAP earnings: By focusing on cash and economic reality rather than accounting conventions, owner's earnings gives a clearer picture of true profitability.

2. Accounts for capital intensity: Unlike metrics like net income, owner's earnings factors in the capital required to maintain the business.

3. Forward-looking: It considers the cash flow generation potential of the business, not just historical performance.

4. Useful for valuation: Owner's earnings can be used as the cash flow figure in discounted cash flow models.

5. Reveals capital allocation skill: By separating maintenance and growth capex, it shows how efficiently management allocates capital.

Owner's Earnings vs Free Cash Flow

Owner's earnings is similar to free cash flow, but with some key differences:

• Free cash flow subtracts all capital expenditures, while owner's earnings only subtracts maintenance capex
• Owner's earnings adds back non-cash charges beyond just depreciation/amortization
• Free cash flow includes changes in working capital, while owner's earnings typically does not

In many cases, owner's earnings will be higher than reported free cash flow because it doesn't penalize a company for growth investments. This makes it especially useful for analyzing high-growth companies that are investing heavily in expansion.

Using Owner's Earnings in Investment Analysis

Here are some ways investors can incorporate owner's earnings into their analysis:

1. Valuation

Owner's earnings can be used as the cash flow figure in a discounted cash flow (DCF) model. This often provides a more accurate valuation than using reported earnings or even free cash flow.

You can also look at the owner's earnings yield (owner's earnings / market cap) as a quick valuation metric, similar to earnings yield.

2. Quality Assessment

Comparing owner's earnings to reported earnings and free cash flow can reveal the quality of a company's earnings. Large discrepancies may indicate accounting shenanigans or an unsustainable business model.

3. Capital Allocation

By separating maintenance and growth capex, owner's earnings shows how much a company is investing in growth versus just maintaining its current position. This can reveal management's capital allocation priorities.

4. Industry Comparisons

Owner's earnings allows for better comparisons between companies with different accounting practices or at different stages of their growth cycle.

Limitations of Owner's Earnings

While owner's earnings is a powerful tool, it does have some limitations to be aware of:

1. Subjectivity: Estimating maintenance capex requires judgment and can vary between analysts.

2. Backward-looking: Like any historical metric, it may not capture future changes in the business.

3. Ignores working capital: Changes in working capital can impact cash flow but aren't factored into owner's earnings.

4. May understate cyclical businesses: For cyclical companies, using average owner's earnings over a full cycle may be more appropriate.

5. Doesn't work for all industries: Financial companies and certain other sectors may require different valuation approaches.

Case Study: Analyzing Owner's Earnings

Let's look at a hypothetical example to see how owner's earnings can provide insights:

Company A:

• Net Income: $100 million
• Depreciation & Amortization: $50 million
• Stock-based Compensation: $20 million
• Total Capex: $80 million
• Estimated Maintenance Capex: $40 million

Owner's Earnings Calculation: $100M + $50M + $20M - $40M = $130 million

Compared to:

• Net Income: $100 million
• Free Cash Flow: $90 million ($100M + $50M + $20M - $80M)

In this case, owner's earnings is significantly higher than both net income and free cash flow. This suggests that:

1. The company is investing heavily in growth (difference between total capex and maintenance capex)
2. There are substantial non-cash expenses reducing reported earnings
3. The business may be more profitable than traditional metrics suggest

An investor using only net income or free cash flow might undervalue this company, missing its true cash generation potential.

Expert Opinions on Owner's Earnings

Many value investors consider owner's earnings to be a crucial metric. Here are some perspectives from investing experts:

Warren Buffett: "If we think through these questions, we can gain some insights about what may be called 'owner earnings.' These represent (a) reported earnings plus (b) depreciation, depletion, amortization, and certain other non-cash charges such as Company N's items (1) and (4) less (c) the average annual amount of capitalized expenditures for plant and equipment, etc. that the business requires to fully maintain its long-term competitive position and its unit volume."

Aswath Damodaran: "Owner earnings is a more conservative measure of cash flows to equity than FCFE [Free Cash Flow to Equity], since it assumes that the firm has to reinvest to maintain its assets in place."

Bruce Greenwald: "Owner earnings adjusts for the fact that depreciation understates true maintenance capital expenditures for most businesses."

Implementing Owner's Earnings in Your Investment Process

If you want to incorporate owner's earnings into your investment analysis, here are some steps to follow:

1. Gather financial data: Collect several years of financial statements for the company you're analyzing.

2. Calculate historical owner's earnings: Use the formula provided earlier, estimating maintenance capex as best you can.

3. Compare to other metrics: Look at how owner's earnings compares to net income, free cash flow, and EBITDA over time.

4. Forecast future owner's earnings: Project how owner's earnings might grow in the future based on the company's prospects.

5. Use in valuation: Incorporate owner's earnings into your DCF model or use the owner's earnings yield for quick comparisons.

6. Consider industry context: Understand how owner's earnings typically behaves in the company's industry.

7. Look for explanations of discrepancies: If owner's earnings differs significantly from other metrics, try to understand why.

Common Mistakes When Using Owner's Earnings

While owner's earnings can be a powerful tool, there are some common pitfalls to avoid:

1. Using depreciation as a proxy for maintenance capex: This often understates true maintenance needs, especially for capital-intensive businesses.

2. Ignoring working capital changes: For businesses with volatile working capital needs, owner's earnings may need to be adjusted.

3. Failing to normalize for economic cycles: For cyclical businesses, using a single year's owner's earnings can be misleading.

4. Overlooking non-recurring items: One-time charges or gains should be carefully considered when calculating owner's earnings.

5. Assuming all growth capex is optional: Some industries require continuous investment to stay competitive, blurring the line between maintenance and growth capex.

Owner's Earnings in Different Industries

The usefulness and calculation of owner's earnings can vary significantly across industries:

Technology

For software companies, owner's earnings may be significantly higher than reported earnings due to high stock-based compensation and low capital requirements. However, estimating maintenance capex for R&D-intensive businesses can be challenging.

Manufacturing

Manufacturing companies often have high depreciation charges that may or may not reflect true maintenance capex needs. Understanding the replacement cycle of equipment is crucial.

Retail

Retail businesses may have significant ongoing investments in store remodels and technology. Distinguishing between maintenance and growth capex requires careful analysis of company disclosures.

Utilities

Regulated utilities often have more predictable capital expenditure needs, making owner's earnings calculations more straightforward. However, regulatory requirements can impact the discretionary nature of investments.

Financial Services

Owner's earnings is less commonly used for banks and insurance companies due to their unique business models and regulatory capital requirements.

The Future of Owner's Earnings

As financial reporting evolves, the calculation and use of owner's earnings may change:

1. Improved disclosures: Companies may provide more detailed breakdowns of capital expenditures, making maintenance capex estimates easier.

2. AI and machine learning: Advanced algorithms may help in estimating maintenance capex and other components of owner's earnings.

3. Standardization: Accounting bodies may move towards standardizing non-GAAP metrics like owner's earnings.

4. Integration with ESG: Owner's earnings calculations may need to factor in sustainability-related investments.

5. Focus on intangibles: As the economy becomes more knowledge-based, owner's earnings methodologies may evolve to better capture investments in intangible assets.

Conclusion

Owner's earnings is a powerful tool for value investors seeking to understand the true economic profitability of a business. By focusing on the cash flow available to owners and accounting for the capital intensity of the business, it provides insights that other financial metrics may miss.

While calculating owner's earnings requires some subjective judgments, particularly around maintenance capital expenditures, the effort can lead to more accurate valuations and a deeper understanding of a company's financial position.

As with any financial metric, owner's earnings should not be used in isolation. It's most effective when combined with other analytical tools and a thorough understanding of the business and its industry. By incorporating owner's earnings into your investment process, you can gain a valuable perspective on a company's true earning power and potential for long-term value creation.

Article created from: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3lBRgVn-j1s