Mexico's Economic Integration with the US: Opportunities and Challenges

The Rise of Nearshoring in Mexico

In recent years, there has been a significant shift in global manufacturing and supply chains, with many companies moving production from China to Mexico. This trend, known as nearshoring, has been driven by several factors, including rising costs in China, trade tensions between the US and China, and the desire for shorter, more resilient supply chains.

The Mexican Moment

Many observers are calling this the "Mexican Moment" - a time of unprecedented opportunity for Mexico to boost its manufacturing sector and strengthen its economic ties with the United States. One company taking advantage of this trend is Plasti Exports, a Monterrey-based manufacturer run by CEO Balwin Britton.

Britton oversees several factories in northern Mexico that produce plastic products and components. One of the plants manufactures kitchen containers. "We're making consumer products here that we sell to the United States, which came from nearshoring projects because these products used to be made in China and are now moving to Mexico," Britton explains.

Shifting Trade Patterns

The numbers clearly show this shift in trade patterns:

• In 2018, 21% of US imports came from China
• By 2023, China's share had fallen to less than 14%
• Meanwhile, Mexico's share of US imports rose from around 13% in 2018 to over 15% in 2023

This closer integration between Mexico and the US was initiated by the 1994 North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA), which included Canada, the US, and Mexico. The agreement's promise and the opportunities it generated attracted many to Mexico, including David Eaton, a young American who was an advisor on the treaty at the time.

Building the Infrastructure for Integration

Eaton has remained in Monterrey since then and is now the Director of Business Development in Mexico for the Canadian Pacific Kansas City railway network. His goal is to build a rail system stretching from northern Canada through the US to southern Mexico, forming what he calls the "backbone of nearshoring."

"How fast is that need for freight growing right now?" Eaton is asked. He responds, "We are investing and preparing during the planning phase as there are many announcements from companies like BMW, Volvo, Mattel, Lego, ArcelorMittal, and Ternium indicating great potential for growth and development in the sector."

Chinese Companies Enter the Mexican Market

Interestingly, it's not just North American companies taking advantage of Mexico's manufacturing capabilities. Britton notes that Chinese multinationals are also setting up operations in Mexico:

"Thirty years ago, there was a shift in business operations from Mexico to China, but in the last 4 years, we saw many companies return to Mexico. Chinese companies are coming to compete with you? Yes, they are coming to Mexico and setting up manufacturing plants. In fact, they are starting their operations in the state of Nuevo León, which is the center."

This trend is reminiscent of the rapid industrialization seen in Chinese cities like Shenzhen, which grew from a small town of 30,000 to a manufacturing hub of over 20 million in just 35 years. Some observers wonder if a similar transformation could happen in parts of Mexico.

Challenges of Doing Business in Mexico

Despite the opportunities, setting up operations in Mexico comes with its own set of challenges. Alan Russell, CEO of Tecma, specializes in helping companies establish and manage factories in Mexico and navigate the difficulties and bureaucracy.

"We have experience in Mexico and help companies avoid difficulties and the time needed to learn to navigate the market on their own," Russell explains. When asked about efforts to harmonize differences in regulations, tax laws, and other areas over his 38 years of experience, Russell notes that things have actually become more complex: "There are more rules and regulations today. It's all more complex than ever."

The Role of Government in Facilitating Integration

For the US and Mexico to fully capitalize on the potential of closer economic integration, both governments will need to work together. This will depend on the plans of Mexico's new president, Claudia Sheinbaum, and how they might be affected by the upcoming US elections.

Marcelo Ebrard, Mexico's newly appointed Economic Secretary, is optimistic about the potential for increased integration. Ebrard, who previously served as Foreign Minister under President Andrés Manuel López Obrador, led Mexico's negotiations for the United States-Mexico-Canada Agreement (USMCA) that replaced NAFTA.

"It definitely doesn't make sense to oppose USMCA because it is, without a doubt, the best deal that has ever existed between our countries. That's the reality," Ebrard states.

Challenges and Opportunities

However, Ebrard acknowledges several challenges that need to be addressed:

1. Energy Infrastructure: Mexico needs to expand its energy capabilities to meet ambitious renewable energy goals set by President Sheinbaum. This will require significant private capital investment.

2. Regulatory Environment: Mexico has too many regulations, which Ebrard plans to reduce drastically to simplify life for investors.

3. Attracting Foreign Investment: Ebrard emphasizes the need for a close relationship with private capital and a friendly approach to facilitate decision-making by foreign companies.

4. Updating USMCA: The upcoming 2026 review of USMCA presents an opportunity to improve the agreement and develop a shared vision for key sectors like microchips, medical equipment, and other relevant industries.

The Future of US-Mexico Economic Integration

Ebrard sees enormous potential in closer economic integration between the US and Mexico. He believes that with the right agreements and a shared vision with US private capital, Mexico could potentially account for about 25% of North American imports.

"We could change the country in just 10 years, why not?" Ebrard says optimistically.

However, realizing this potential will require addressing several key challenges:

1. Energy Infrastructure

One of the most pressing issues is Mexico's energy infrastructure. The country needs to significantly expand its capacity to meet growing demand from manufacturers and achieve its renewable energy goals.

President Sheinbaum has set ambitious targets for renewable energy, aiming for 40% by 2030. Achieving this will require substantial private investment. Ebrard acknowledges this, stating, "The idea is to attract private capital and take responsibility jointly."

2. Regulatory Environment

Mexico's complex regulatory environment is often cited as a major hurdle for businesses. Ebrard recognizes this issue and plans to address it:

"We can reduce many regulations. This country has too many regulations, that's true, and we're going to change this. It doesn't make sense as it only makes people waste time. Our main goal is to streamline processes to accelerate investment."

3. Security Concerns

Security remains a significant concern for investors in Mexico. Homicide rates remain near record highs, and problems such as extortion, embezzlement, and various forms of kidnapping have been on the rise.

Shannon O'Neil, Vice President of the Council on Foreign Relations, notes that this creates uncertainty, which investors dislike. Addressing these security issues will be crucial for attracting and retaining foreign investment.

4. Political Uncertainty

The upcoming US elections and the 2026 review of USMCA add an element of political uncertainty to the future of US-Mexico economic integration. The outcome of these events could significantly impact trade policies and investment decisions.

5. Competition with China

While Mexico has benefited from companies moving production away from China, it also faces new competition from Chinese companies setting up operations in Mexico. This presents both opportunities and challenges for Mexican manufacturers and policymakers.

Potential Benefits of Closer Integration

Despite these challenges, closer economic integration between the US and Mexico offers significant potential benefits for both countries:

1. Resilient Supply Chains

Nearshoring can help create more resilient supply chains by reducing dependence on distant suppliers and minimizing disruptions caused by global events like the COVID-19 pandemic.

2. Job Creation

Increased manufacturing activity in Mexico can create jobs on both sides of the border. As Eaton points out, "When we carry out manufacturing in Mexico, more synergies are generated and more job opportunities are created in the United States."

3. Economic Growth

Closer integration could drive economic growth in both countries. For Mexico, it presents an opportunity to significantly expand its manufacturing sector and move up the value chain.

4. Improved Competitiveness

By working together, the US and Mexico (along with Canada under USMCA) can improve their collective competitiveness in key industries like semiconductors, electric vehicles, and pharmaceuticals.

5. Geopolitical Alignment

Stronger economic ties can reinforce geopolitical alignment between the US and Mexico, potentially leading to closer cooperation on other issues.

Conclusion

The growing economic integration between Mexico and the United States presents significant opportunities for both countries. Mexico's "nearshoring moment" could transform its economy and strengthen its position in global supply chains. For the US, closer integration with Mexico offers the potential for more resilient supply chains and improved competitiveness in key industries.

However, realizing these benefits will require addressing several challenges, including infrastructure needs, regulatory complexity, security concerns, and political uncertainties. It will also necessitate careful navigation of the changing global economic landscape, particularly in relation to China.

As Ebrard suggests, success will depend on developing a shared vision and a long-term strategy that goes beyond simple free trade to encompass collaborative efforts to boost competitiveness across key sectors. With the right policies and investments, the next decade could indeed see a transformation of the Mexican economy and a new era of North American economic cooperation.

Ultimately, the story of US-Mexico economic integration is one of potential - potential that, if properly harnessed, could yield significant benefits for both nations. However, it's also a story that underscores the complexities of international trade and the careful balancing act required to navigate global economic shifts while addressing domestic concerns and priorities.

As both countries move forward, maintaining open dialogue, addressing mutual concerns, and fostering a spirit of collaboration will be crucial. The "Mexican Moment" presents an opportunity, but seizing it will require sustained effort, strategic thinking, and a willingness to adapt to the evolving global economic landscape.

Article created from: https://youtu.be/RH987NRm0bA?feature=shared