The Impact of Gaza's Health Crisis on Israeli Public Opinion

The ongoing conflict between Israel and Hamas has had profound impacts on public opinion within Israel regarding the humanitarian crisis in Gaza. While there are diverse views among Israelis, several key factors have shaped attitudes:

The October 7th Hamas Attack

The October 7th, 2023 Hamas attack on Israeli civilians, which killed over 1,000 people and led to the taking of hostages, had a major impact on Israeli public opinion. It created a sense of shock, grief, and fear among Israelis, leading to strong support for military action against Hamas.

Divisions in Israeli Society

There are significant divisions in Israeli society that affect views on Gaza:

• Jewish Israelis vs. Arab/Palestinian citizens of Israel have very different perspectives, with Arab citizens generally opposing military action
• Within Jewish Israeli society, there are divisions between left, right, and center political ideologies
• The right-wing, which is the majority, tends to be more supportive of aggressive military action and less concerned about the humanitarian situation in Gaza
• The left-wing and centrists, who make up about 40% of Jewish Israelis, are more likely to support humanitarian aid and be concerned about civilian casualties

Government Messaging and Media Coverage

The Israeli government's messaging and media coverage have shaped public perceptions:

• There has been limited coverage of the humanitarian crisis in Gaza in Israeli media
• Government officials have made statements justifying cutting off food, water, and fuel to Gaza as necessary in wartime
• This has contributed to a lack of awareness or concern among many Israelis about the severity of the situation

Historical Context

Many Israelis view the current situation through the lens of Israel's 2005 withdrawal from Gaza:

• There is a common perception that Israel "gave Gaza" to Palestinians, who then elected Hamas
• This leads many to feel Israel bears no responsibility for conditions in Gaza
• There is limited awareness of Israel's continued control over Gaza's borders, airspace, and economy since 2005

Security Concerns

Many Israelis view the humanitarian crisis primarily through the lens of security:

• There are fears that allowing more aid into Gaza will benefit Hamas
• The October 7th attack reinforced views that security must take precedence over humanitarian concerns

International Pressure

International criticism and potential legal action have had some impact:

• There is concern among some Israelis about accusations of war crimes at the International Criminal Court
• However, many feel the international community unfairly singles out Israel for criticism

Potential for Cooperation on Public Health

Despite the overall negative attitudes, there is some potential for cooperation between Israelis and Palestinians on public health issues:

Historical Precedents

There are past examples of successful Israeli-Palestinian cooperation on public health:

• In 2006, Israeli, Palestinian, and Jordanian health officials worked together to contain avian flu outbreaks
• During the COVID-19 pandemic, there was some coordination on training and containment efforts

Common Epidemiological Space

There is growing recognition that Israelis and Palestinians share a "common epidemiological space":

• Disease outbreaks in Gaza can easily spread to Israel
• Water and sanitation issues in Gaza impact Israeli water sources

Polio Outbreak

A recent polio outbreak in Gaza highlights the need for cooperation:

• Wastewater samples from June 2023 confirmed ongoing polio transmission
• There have been at least 3 confirmed cases, including in a 10-month-old infant
• UNICEF and WHO are planning vaccination campaigns for 640,000 children
• This requires coordination with Israeli authorities for access and supplies

Government Pragmatism

Despite public rhetoric, the Israeli government has shown some pragmatism on health cooperation:

• It has allowed fuel into Gaza for water treatment plants
• There is coordination on allowing patients from Gaza into Israeli hospitals
• The government knows how to manage these efforts quietly when needed

Challenges to Cooperation

However, there are significant obstacles to expanded health cooperation:

Political Climate

• The current Israeli government relies on far-right coalition partners opposed to cooperation with Palestinians
• There is a toxic relationship between Israeli leadership and UN agencies

Ongoing Military Operations

• Intense fighting makes it difficult to implement health initiatives like vaccination campaigns
• The Israeli military is focused on combat operations, not humanitarian efforts

Public Opinion

• Many Israelis remain skeptical of cooperation with Palestinians
• There is limited public pressure for the government to prioritize Gaza's health needs

Potential Ways Forward

Despite the challenges, there are some potential ways to advance health cooperation:

Framing Cooperation as Self-Interest

• Emphasize to Israelis how Gaza's health crisis impacts their own health and security
• Make pragmatic arguments about disease spread rather than moral appeals

Quiet Diplomacy

• The Israeli government could take pragmatic steps without much public attention
• Small-scale, localized cooperation may be more feasible than large initiatives

Leadership from Health Professionals

• Israeli and Palestinian health experts could drive cooperation efforts
• Professional-to-professional relationships may be easier than political ones

International Support

• UN agencies and NGOs can facilitate cooperation even when political tensions are high
• External funding and expertise can enable joint health projects

Conclusion

While Israeli public opinion currently presents significant obstacles to addressing Gaza's health crisis, there are some grounds for cautious optimism. By emphasizing shared interests, building on past examples of cooperation, and taking pragmatic steps, it may be possible to make progress on critical public health issues that impact both Israelis and Palestinians. However, this will require leadership and political will to overcome the current climate of hostility and separation.

Article created from: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mKRKEPJE4UU