Giants 2025 NFL Draft Strategy: Expert Insights and Predictions

The Giants' 2025 NFL Draft Approach

As the 2025 NFL Draft approaches, the New York Giants find themselves in a pivotal position with the third overall pick. With numerous options on the table, from selecting a blue-chip defensive player to potentially trading up for a quarterback, the Giants' draft strategy is a hot topic among fans and analysts alike.

To gain expert insight into the Giants' potential moves, we turned to Todd McShay, a respected draft analyst now working with The Ringer and Spotify. McShay shared his thoughts on the Giants' options, the quarterback market, and how the team might approach their multiple picks in the early rounds.

The Third Overall Pick: A Crucial Decision

According to McShay, the Giants' decision at number three largely depends on who is available. He suggests that if Abdul Carter or Travis Hunter are still on the board, they would be hard to pass up. These players are considered blue-chip prospects who could immediately impact the Giants' defense.

However, McShay also notes that there's been increasing chatter about the Giants potentially considering a quarterback with their first pick. This speculation has been fueled by recent private workouts the team has conducted with several top quarterback prospects.

The Quarterback Conundrum

One of the most intriguing aspects of this year's draft is the late flurry of activity surrounding the quarterback position. McShay points out that it's unusual to see so many quarterbacks flying to organizations for workouts this close to the draft, and vice versa.

He specifically mentions Shedeur Sanders as a player generating significant interest. While McShay doesn't believe Sanders will go in the top 10 picks, he suggests that several teams, including the Giants, are doing extensive work on him and other quarterbacks like Jackson Dart, Jaylen Milroe, and Tyler Shough.

Potential Trade Scenarios

McShay outlines a fascinating scenario where teams like the Giants, Cleveland Browns, and New Orleans Saints might take the best player available with their early first-round picks, then look to trade back into the first round to select a quarterback. He suggests that picks in the 20s could be prime targets for such moves.

For the Giants specifically, McShay proposes a strategy where they could take Abdul Carter at three, then potentially trade up from their second-round pick (34th overall) to secure a quarterback like Sanders or Dart.

Comparing the Second-Tier Quarterbacks

If the Giants decide to wait until the second round to address the quarterback position, they could have options like Jackson Dart, Jaylen Milroe, and Tyler Shough available. McShay breaks down the differences between these prospects:

• Jackson Dart: Strong arm, mobile, sturdy build. McShay sees him as potentially ready to play by 2026.
• Jaylen Milroe: Incredible athlete with a high football IQ, but needs time to develop. McShay views him as more of a 2027 project.
• Tyler Shough: Not specifically discussed, but mentioned as part of this second tier of quarterbacks.

Addressing Other Team Needs

Beyond quarterback, McShay identifies several other areas where the Giants could look to improve through the draft:

• Defensive Tackle: Players like Kenneth Grant from Michigan or Walter Nolen could be options to pair with Dexter Lawrence.
• Offensive Guard: Gray Fable from North Dakota State or Tyler Booker from Alabama could bolster the offensive line.
• Running Back: While not an immediate need, McShay suggests the Giants could find value later in the draft with players like Devin Neal from Kansas.

McShay's Ideal Giants Draft

When asked to outline his ideal draft for the Giants, McShay proposed the following strategy:

1. Select Abdul Carter at #3 overall
2. Trade back into the first round (potentially with Minnesota) to select a quarterback like Jackson Dart or Tyler Shough
3. Use remaining picks to address needs at defensive tackle, offensive guard, and potentially running back

McShay emphasizes the importance of balancing immediate impact players with long-term projects, particularly at the quarterback position.

Key Takeaways for Giants Fans

1. The Giants have multiple options with the third overall pick, including taking a defensive star or potentially surprising with a quarterback selection.
2. There's significant interest in quarterbacks beyond the top tier, with private workouts continuing late into the pre-draft process.
3. Trading back into the first round for a quarterback is a real possibility for the Giants and other QB-needy teams.
4. The second tier of quarterbacks (Dart, Milroe, Shough) offer different skillsets and development timelines.
5. Defensive tackle and offensive guard are other positions of need that could be addressed early in the draft.

Conclusion

As the 2025 NFL Draft approaches, the New York Giants find themselves in a position of both opportunity and complexity. With needs across multiple positions and the potential to dramatically reshape their roster, the decisions made by Joe Schoen and the front office will be crucial in determining the team's future success.

Whether they opt for an immediate impact defender like Abdul Carter, make a bold move for a quarterback, or execute a series of trades to maximize value, Giants fans can expect an exciting and potentially transformative draft. As Todd McShay's analysis shows, the possibilities are numerous, and the stakes are high.

As we count down the final hours to the draft, one thing is certain: the New York Giants' 2025 draft class will be a defining moment for the franchise, setting the course for years to come. Fans should buckle up for what promises to be a thrilling and unpredictable draft night.

Article created from: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fe55XqX9DUw