The Future of Post-Collapse Russia: Geopolitical Implications and Regional Shifts

The Potential for Russian Collapse

While the idea of a Russian collapse may seem far-fetched to some, there are several factors that suggest it could be a possibility in the coming decades. The current Russian demographics are concerning, and the ongoing war in Ukraine is not progressing favorably for Russia. However, it's important to note that such a collapse is not imminent and is unlikely to occur within the next few years or even this decade.

For a Russian collapse to occur, we would need to see a significant political upheaval where the Putin regime fails. Given that Putin has systematically removed potential successors from positions of power, a leadership struggle and possible civil conflict would likely ensue, ultimately leading to national collapse. Barring a massive military defeat in Ukraine in the near term, this scenario remains a distant possibility rather than an immediate concern.

The Post-Russian Landscape

In the event of a Russian collapse, several key areas would be affected, reshaping the geopolitical landscape of the region. Let's examine these areas in detail:

Military Technology and Hardware

Russia has long been considered a military power, second only to the United States during the Cold War. However, the ongoing conflict in Ukraine has exposed significant weaknesses in Russia's military capabilities, particularly in its ability to produce advanced technology at scale.

Some key points to consider:

• Russia's more advanced tanks can only be produced one at a time
• Only a dozen advanced jets have been manufactured in the last 15 years
• The industrial capacity to transfer this technology to another power is limited
• Chinese technological capabilities are not sophisticated enough to replicate the more advanced Russian systems
• Countries with the technical skills to utilize Russian technology (e.g., Poland, Ukraine, Czech Republic, Hungary) prefer working with more effective and advanced Western technology

Given these factors, it's unlikely that Russian military hardware would pose a significant threat in the hands of other nations following a collapse. Much of the existing equipment is being depleted in the Ukraine war, further reducing the potential for other countries to acquire and utilize Russian military technology.

Skilled Labor and Brain Drain

The exodus of skilled professionals from Russia is a phenomenon we've seen before, following the collapse of the Soviet Union. In the current context, we can expect a similar trend, albeit on a smaller scale:

• Approximately 1 million men have already fled Russia since the beginning of the Ukraine war
• Estimates of Russian casualties in the war range from 300,000 to 800,000
• After the Soviet collapse, around 10 million Russians with advanced degrees left the country

However, the potential for brain drain in a future collapse would be less dramatic due to several factors:

• The Russian educational system, particularly in technical fields, collapsed before the Soviet Union and was never fully rebuilt
• There are fewer people with advanced degrees remaining in the country
• The skills of those who have remained have often atrophied under the current system

While there will likely be an outflow of skilled professionals, including those from intelligence services, the impact will be less significant than what was observed in the 1990s.

Intelligence Personnel and Criminal Activities

Following a collapse, we can expect some former intelligence personnel to engage in criminal activities, similar to what occurred after the fall of the Soviet Union. However, the scale and sophistication of these activities may be different:

• The pool of highly skilled intelligence operatives is smaller than it was in the 1990s
• Current Russian security personnel are often more akin to enforcers than sophisticated intelligence agents
• The lack of global connections that Soviet-era operatives possessed will limit the reach of these individuals
• The skills valued in Putin's system, such as personal loyalty, are less marketable in a post-collapse scenario

While there will likely be an increase in criminal activities by former security personnel, the global impact may be less significant than what was seen following the Soviet collapse.

Resource Management and Economic Implications

Russia's vast natural resources have long been a cornerstone of its economic power. However, a collapse would significantly impact the country's ability to manage and exploit these resources effectively.

Agricultural Production

Russian agriculture has undergone significant changes since the Soviet era, with a split between traditional and modern farming methods:

• Approximately 80% of farms still use Soviet-style, input-intensive, and inefficient methods
• The remaining 20% are "Enterprise Farms" using Western equipment, technology, and inputs
• Enterprise Farms are more productive and generate more income, despite being fewer in number

In a post-collapse scenario, several issues could arise:

• Enterprise Farms are dependent on international supply chains, which may be disrupted
• If these farms lose access to necessary inputs, they may revert to less efficient methods
• Overall agricultural output could decrease significantly
• Distribution issues, a historical problem for Russia, could worsen

While widespread famine is unlikely, food security could become a significant concern in certain regions.

Mineral and Energy Resources

Russia's mineral wealth is vast but challenging to access and extract. In a collapse scenario, several factors would complicate resource exploitation:

• Many key resources are located in remote, harsh environments (e.g., high Arctic, Siberia)
• Extraction requires sophisticated infrastructure and ongoing maintenance
• Russia's educational system collapse has led to a shortage of qualified personnel
• Many operations rely on Western technology and expertise

For foreign powers to exploit these resources post-collapse, they would need to:

• Invest significant capital
• Bring in their own technology and expertise
• Provide security in often hostile environments
• Establish new supply chains in extremely remote areas

Given these challenges, it's likely that only the most accessible resources in border regions would continue to be exploited in the short term.

Ethnic Dynamics and Potential Breakaway Regions

Russia's ethnic composition plays a crucial role in understanding potential fracture lines in a collapse scenario. Official Russian statistics, which likely underestimate the diversity, suggest that 20% of the population is non-ethnic Russian.

Key ethnic minority regions to watch include:

1. Western Siberia: Pockets of Germans and Ukrainians
2. Southern Russia: Tatars, Bashkirs, Chechens, and Ingush
3. Northwestern Russia: Finnic minorities

Tatars and Bashkirs

These groups are particularly significant due to their strategic location and resources:

• Located northwest of Kazakhstan
• Control key infrastructure connecting Russia and Siberia
• Possess significant energy reserves
• Retained much of their technical expertise after the Soviet collapse

If these regions were to break away, it could effectively cut off Siberia from European Russia and create a new, potentially viable state.

Caucasus Region

The Caucasus, particularly Chechnya, is another area of potential instability:

• Many minorities in this region are Turkic
• Turkey has historically shown interest in the region, supporting Chechen independence movements
• A breakaway in this region could severely limit Russia's influence in the Caucasus and impact its ability to pressure Ukraine

Northwestern Finnic Minorities

The northwestern region, home to Finnic minorities, could see involvement from Scandinavian countries:

• Finland lost significant territory to the Soviet Union after World War II
• Sweden and Finland are now part of the Western alliance and have become increasingly assertive
• These countries have robust military traditions and could seek to reclaim lost territories or expand their influence

International Responses and Regional Power Shifts

A Russian collapse would inevitably trigger responses from neighboring countries and global powers. Some potential scenarios include:

Chinese Involvement

China, as Russia's largest neighbor and a rising global power, would likely seek to protect its interests:

• May attempt to secure energy resources in Siberia
• Could try to expand its influence in Central Asia
• Might face challenges in dealing with unstable border regions

European Union and NATO

Western powers would need to carefully balance their approach:

• Potential expansion of influence into former Russian territories
• Concerns about the security of nuclear weapons and materials
• Humanitarian aid and stabilization efforts in certain regions

Central Asian States

Former Soviet republics in Central Asia could see significant changes:

• Potential for increased autonomy and regional cooperation
• Risk of instability due to shifting power dynamics
• Opportunities for new economic and political alignments

Turkey and the Middle East

Turkey, in particular, may seek to expand its influence:

• Support for Turkic minorities in Russia
• Potential involvement in the Caucasus region
• Opportunities to strengthen its position as a regional power

Long-term Implications and Global Impact

The collapse of Russia would have far-reaching consequences beyond its immediate borders:

Global Energy Markets

• Disruption of oil and gas supplies
• Potential for price volatility and energy security concerns
• Opportunities for other producers to fill the gap

Nuclear Security

• Ensuring the safety and security of Russia's nuclear arsenal would be a top priority
• International cooperation may be necessary to prevent proliferation

Geopolitical Balance

• Shift in the global power structure
• Potential for increased regional conflicts
• New alliances and partnerships may emerge

Economic Ripple Effects

• Disruption of global supply chains
• Impact on countries economically dependent on Russia
• Potential for new economic opportunities in the region

Conclusion

While a Russian collapse is not imminent, the potential for such an event in the coming decades cannot be ignored. The aftermath of such a collapse would reshape the geopolitical landscape of Eurasia and have significant global implications.

Key takeaways include:

1. The dispersal of military technology and skilled labor would be less impactful than following the Soviet collapse
2. Resource exploitation would face significant challenges, particularly in remote regions
3. Ethnic minority regions could seek independence, potentially fragmenting the Russian state
4. International powers would likely seek to influence and stabilize the region
5. Global energy markets and security concerns would be significantly affected

As we move forward, it's crucial for policymakers, analysts, and global leaders to consider these potential scenarios and prepare for the complex challenges that a post-collapse Russian space might present. While the future remains uncertain, understanding the dynamics at play can help in developing strategies to address potential instabilities and opportunities in this critical region.

Article created from: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FQEa7t-Jjgo