ESAL ETF: High-Income Strategy with Volatility Premium

Understanding the VIX and ESAL ETF

The ESAL ETF (Simplify Volatility Premium ETF) is an innovative investment vehicle that aims to generate consistent high income by capitalizing on the volatility premium in the market. To comprehend how ESAL functions, it's crucial to first understand the VIX index, which forms the foundation of this ETF's strategy.

What is the VIX?

The VIX, often referred to as the "fear index" or "volatility index," is derived from the ratio of put options to call options on the S&P 500. Here's a breakdown of what this means:

• Put options: Bets on the market going down
• Call options: Bets on the market going up

When there's a higher ratio of puts to calls, it indicates more people are betting on the market to decline, resulting in a higher VIX value. While it's called a volatility index, it's more accurate to describe it as a fear index or a measure of expected downside volatility.

The VIX typically hovers in the 15-20 range during calm market periods but is prone to rapid, short-term spikes during times of market turmoil. Historical examples of such spikes include the dot-com bubble burst and the 2008 financial crisis.

VIX Futures and Contango

The VIX itself is not a tangible asset that can be directly purchased. Instead, investors can gain exposure to VIX through the futures market. VIX futures contracts are priced for different expiration months, and a key characteristic of these futures is that they're often in contango.

Contango refers to a situation where futures prices are higher for contracts with later expiration dates. This pricing structure exists because investors are willing to pay a premium for protection against potential market downturns. It's akin to purchasing insurance - people are willing to pay for it, even though it doesn't pay off most of the time.

The ESAL Strategy

ESAL's primary strategy involves shorting VIX futures, essentially taking the opposite position of those buying VIX futures for protection. This approach aims to capitalize on the tendency of VIX futures prices to decline over time due to contango.

However, simply shorting VIX futures can be extremely risky, as evidenced by the fate of the now-defunct XIV ETF, which lost nearly all its value in a single day during a VIX spike. ESAL employs several risk management techniques to mitigate such extreme outcomes:

1. Limited leverage: ESAL uses only 0.2 to 0.3 times leverage when shorting VIX futures, significantly reducing its exposure compared to other volatility-shorting ETFs.

2. Dynamic exposure management: The ETF adjusts its exposure based on VIX levels. When VIX is low (indicating higher risk), ESAL sells longer-term futures (4-6 months out) to reduce potential losses during VIX spikes.

3. Hedging: ESAL buys out-of-the-money VIX call options or stock market put options as a form of insurance against extreme market events.

4. Diversification: Only about 25% of ESAL's portfolio is dedicated to shorting VIX futures. The remainder is invested in income-producing securities like short-term Treasury bills, which can act as a natural hedge during market downturns.

ESAL's Performance and Income Generation

ESAL aims to achieve two primary objectives:

1. Generate consistent income
2. Maintain downside risk similar to the S&P 500

Let's examine how ESAL has performed in terms of income consistency, downside protection, and overall returns.

Income Consistency

Since mid-2022, ESAL has focused on maintaining a consistent income stream. The ETF's income doesn't primarily come from traditional income-producing securities. Instead, it's derived from the "roll yield" - the return generated as futures prices decrease over time due to contango.

ESAL combines this roll yield with returns from its bond positions to create a steady income stream. The fund managers estimate the long-term roll yield plus bond yield and aim to match that with a smooth, consistent payout over time.

While there may be occasional adjustments to the payout (such as the recent reduction from 30 cents to 28 cents per share), the goal is to maintain a relatively stable income level over time.

Downside Protection

ESAL's price performance (excluding dividends) has closely tracked the S&P 500 during market downturns, such as those experienced in 2022. This alignment with broad market movements is by design, as ESAL aims to keep its downside risk profile similar to that of the S&P 500.

It's important to note that because ESAL distributes most of its returns as income, investors shouldn't expect significant share price appreciation over time. In fact, since its inception (approximately 3.5 years ago), ESAL's share price has declined by about 13.3%, while the S&P 500's price has increased by over 40% during the same period.

Total Return Performance

Despite the decline in share price, ESAL's total return (with dividends reinvested) has been competitive with the S&P 500. It has significantly outperformed many other high-income strategies, such as covered call ETFs like JEPI and XYLD.

The key advantage of ESAL over covered call strategies is that it doesn't cap upside potential, allowing for better recovery from losses and potentially higher long-term returns.

ESAL in a Portfolio Context

Given its unique characteristics, how might ESAL fit into an investment portfolio? Let's consider two perspectives: that of a long-term growth investor and an income-focused investor.

For Long-Term Growth Investors

For growth-oriented investors, ESAL can serve as a diversifier within the equity portion of a portfolio. While traditional diversification often involves allocating between growth and value stocks or U.S. and international equities, ESAL offers a different type of diversification.

In flat or range-bound markets, where traditional stock market indexes might struggle to generate returns, ESAL's strategy has the potential to outperform. By allocating a portion of their equity exposure to ESAL and reinvesting all dividends, growth investors can potentially enhance their portfolio's diversification and long-term return potential.

For Income Investors

For income-focused investors, ESAL presents a compelling opportunity. While the ETF aims to provide stable distributions, it's important to note that these distributions are not likely to increase over time. However, the high yield (currently around 15-17%) combined with the potential for capital appreciation makes ESAL an attractive option for creating a sustainable, growing income stream.

Here's a hypothetical strategy for income investors:

1. Invest in ESAL
2. Instead of taking all distributions as income, reinvest a portion
3. Implement a systematic withdrawal plan, taking out a more conservative amount (e.g., 8% annually)
4. Increase withdrawals annually to match inflation

This approach could potentially create a sustainable, growing income stream while allowing the investment to appreciate over time. For example, if an investor started with $100,000 in ESAL and implemented this strategy:

• They could initially withdraw $8,000 per year (split into monthly payments)
• Increase withdrawals annually to keep pace with inflation
• Reinvest the remaining 6-10% of distributions
• Potentially see their investment grow over time, even while taking regular withdrawals

While this strategy isn't guaranteed, it offers a potential solution for income investors seeking high yields without sacrificing long-term sustainability.

Risk Considerations

While ESAL's strategy appears promising, it's crucial to understand and consider the risks involved:

1. Volatility exposure: Despite risk mitigation techniques, ESAL is still exposed to potential losses during extreme market events or VIX spikes.

2. Complex strategy: The use of VIX futures and options makes ESAL more complex than traditional equity or bond investments, which may make it challenging for some investors to fully understand.

3. Limited track record: ESAL is a relatively new ETF, so its long-term performance in various market conditions remains to be seen.

4. Interest rate sensitivity: The bond portion of ESAL's portfolio may be affected by changes in interest rates.

5. Potential for strategy adjustments: The fund managers may need to adjust their approach over time, which could impact returns or income consistency.

Conclusion

The ESAL ETF represents an innovative approach to generating high income through volatility premium capture. Its unique strategy of shorting VIX futures, combined with robust risk management techniques, offers investors a potential alternative to traditional high-income investments.

For long-term growth investors, ESAL can serve as a diversifier within the equity portion of a portfolio, potentially enhancing returns in flat or range-bound markets. For income-focused investors, ESAL's high yield and total return potential make it an attractive option for creating a sustainable, growing income stream when used responsibly.

However, as with any investment, it's crucial to thoroughly understand the risks and how ESAL fits within your overall investment strategy and goals. Consider consulting with a financial advisor to determine if ESAL is appropriate for your specific situation.

In the ever-evolving landscape of investment products, ESAL stands out as a unique offering that merits consideration for investors seeking high income or portfolio diversification. As always, careful research and a clear understanding of your investment objectives should guide your decision-making process.

Article created from: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i62zojkyXIQ