Create articles from any YouTube video or use our API to get YouTube transcriptions
Start for freeUnraveling the Beatles' Music Theory Mystery
Over the past few years, the debate about the Beatles' understanding of music theory has been a hot topic among music enthusiasts. Some argue that the Beatles, one of the most influential bands in history, had little to no knowledge of music theory, while others believe they were masters of it. Composer Howard Goodall even goes as far as to describe Paul McCartney as a composer who "really knows what he's doing." But how much of this is true? Did the Beatles really know music theory, and does it even matter when analyzing their music?
The Beatles and Sheet Music
It's a well-known fact that the Beatles didn't read or write traditional sheet music. They themselves have admitted to not seeing music in that form, which led many to believe they lacked a basic understanding of music theory. However, understanding theory goes beyond just reading and writing notation. Music theory encompasses how music is learned, written, arranged, and performed, and it's evident that the Beatles had their own approach to these aspects.
Rhythm and Time Signatures
One of the fundamental aspects of music theory is rhythm, including the counting of beats and bars. An example of the Beatles' understanding of this can be seen in how Paul McCartney counts in "All My Loving". He counts "one, two, three, four, one" to indicate the song starts on the third beat of the bar, a technique ensuring the band was synchronized. Additionally, their awareness of changing time signatures, for instance, shifting from 4/4 to 3/4 in "We Can Work It Out", indicates a practical understanding of rhythm, even if they didn't use the formal terminology.
Chords and Key Changes
The Beatles' knowledge of chords, including major, minor, and more complex variations, was largely self-taught and developed through their experiences. Stories of them traveling across Liverpool to learn a new chord, such as B7, showcase their dedication to expanding their musical vocabulary. Furthermore, their experimentation with chord inversions and the use of advanced chords like 6th, 9th, and 11th in their songs suggest a more sophisticated understanding of harmony.
Their approach to key changes, another complex aspect of music theory, was intuitive. They might not have always used the correct technical terms, but they were certainly aware of the effect of moving from one key to another. For example, Paul McCartney's description of the writing process for "Here, There and Everywhere" shows an understanding that chords belong together in a key.
Modes and Musical Elements
The Beatles' songs occasionally ventured into modal music, though it's unclear how conscious they were of using modes explicitly. Paul's reflection on the chord change in "I'll Get You" suggests an intuitive understanding of how certain changes could introduce new tonalities, even if not named as such.
The Role of George Martin
George Martin, the Beatles' producer, played a crucial role in bridging the gap between the band's intuitive musical ideas and formal music theory. His formal training allowed him to translate the Beatles' concepts into notation for other musicians, suggesting arrangements, and even contributing to the songwriting process with theoretical insights. This collaboration highlights how theoretical knowledge and musical intuition can complement each other in the creative process.
Conclusion: The Beatles' Theoretical Understanding
While the Beatles may not have had formal training in music theory, their intuitive understanding of music, combined with their experimental approach, allowed them to create songs that were both innovative and technically complex. They knew more than they perhaps realized, and their work with George Martin allowed them to express their musical ideas fully, regardless of their theoretical knowledge. The debate over their understanding of music theory underscores the fact that music can transcend formal education, and creativity can flourish in the absence of technical terminology.
Music theory, rather than being a set of restrictive rules, is a toolkit for understanding and creating music. The Beatles' legacy demonstrates that breaking out of conventional boundaries and exploring music's vast possibilities can lead to groundbreaking results. Their music invites listeners and musicians alike to look under the hood, not to find rules that were followed, but to discover the innovative ways in which music can be understood and created.
For a more in-depth exploration of the Beatles' relationship with music theory, watch the original video here.
