Chinese EV Market Consolidation: The Looming Bankruptcy Crisis

The Oversaturated Chinese EV Market

The Chinese electric vehicle (EV) market is currently experiencing a significant challenge: there are simply too many car brands competing for market share. This oversaturation is not unique to China, but it is particularly pronounced in the world's largest automotive market. Industry experts and CEOs have long predicted that many of these brands would eventually face financial difficulties, and recent events are proving them right.

Recent Bankruptcies in the Chinese EV Sector

In the past year alone, two major and well-known Chinese electric car brands have filed for bankruptcy. This trend is likely to continue, as the current market structure is unsustainable. With approximately 90 EV brands operating in China, industry analysts suggest that this number needs to be reduced dramatically - to somewhere between 10 and 15 brands - for the sector to achieve long-term viability.

The Latest Casualty: Yan Hung

Recent reports from various Chinese automotive news outlets, including Car News China, indicate that another EV manufacturer is on the brink of bankruptcy. The brand in question is Yan Hung, an electric vehicle manufacturer owned by the Deun group.

Signs of Financial Distress

Several indicators point to Yan Hung's dire financial situation:

1. Cessation of wage payments: The company has reportedly stopped paying its employees.
2. Mass exodus of staff: Many employees have either been fired or have voluntarily left the company.
3. Skeleton crew remaining: Reports suggest that only about a dozen employees remain with the company.

Company Response

In response to these reports, Yan Hung has partially acknowledged the truth of these claims. However, they've also stated that executives are continuing to perform their duties as usual. This statement seems to contradict the reports of widespread staff departures and non-payment of wages.

The Broader Context: Market Dynamics

The struggles faced by smaller EV manufacturers like Yan Hung are not occurring in isolation. They are part of a broader trend in the Chinese automotive market, particularly in the EV sector.

Success of Larger Players

While smaller manufacturers struggle, some larger companies are thriving. For instance, one major Chinese EV manufacturer is reportedly on track to deliver 500,000 cars in October alone, with the majority of these sales occurring within China.

This success, however, comes at a cost to smaller players in the market. As larger companies capture more market share, they leave less room for smaller manufacturers to operate profitably.

The Risk of Investing in Smaller EV Companies

The current market dynamics highlight the risks associated with investing in smaller EV companies. While the allure of finding "the next Tesla" is strong, the reality is that most of these companies face significant challenges.

Examples of risky investments in the EV sector include:

1. Lucid: The company's stock price has fallen 44% this year, following previous years of significant declines.
2. Vinfast: The company's IPO resulted in significant losses for many investors.
3. Rivian: Another example of an EV company whose IPO led to substantial investor losses.

These cases underscore the high-risk nature of investing in emerging EV companies, especially in an oversaturated market.

Yan Hung's Financial Struggles

Insiders report that Yan Hung is grappling with severe cash flow problems. The company is actively seeking financing from local government sources and other potential investors. However, given the current market conditions and the fate of other struggling EV manufacturers, the likelihood of securing such funding appears low.

Comparison to Other Bankrupt Chinese EV Brands

Earlier this year, a well-known luxury Chinese EV brand filed for bankruptcy despite having a strong presence both domestically and internationally. This brand was selling more expensive EVs than Porsche and BMW combined in the premium segment. Despite its apparent success and market recognition, it was unable to secure additional funding when financial troubles arose.

This precedent suggests that even established brands with seemingly strong market positions are not immune to the financial pressures facing the Chinese EV industry.

Yan Hung's Official Statement

In response to the reports of financial trouble, Yan Hung has issued a statement claiming that the company is undergoing "strategic adjustment and reorganization." They further stated that the company is in a transitional phase and will resume normal operations once the reorganization is complete.

This language is reminiscent of statements made by other companies shortly before ceasing operations, raising questions about the true state of Yan Hung's finances and future prospects.

The Deun Group Factor

Yan Hung has emphasized its connection to the Deun Group, a large conglomerate with a history dating back to 1987. However, the Deun Group's size and history may not be sufficient to guarantee Yan Hung's survival.

This situation draws parallels to the Evergrande Group, another large Chinese conglomerate that was once considered "too big to fail" but ultimately faced severe financial difficulties. The Evergrande case serves as a reminder that even large, established companies can face bankruptcy in challenging market conditions.

Yan Hung's Market Performance

To understand Yan Hung's current predicament, it's crucial to examine their recent sales performance:

• In the first nine months of this year, Yan Hung sold a total of 5,584 vehicles.
• Their vehicles are positioned in the mid to high-end market, with prices ranging from $42,000 to $70,000.
• The company uses quality parts from reputable suppliers such as Huawei and Bosch.

Despite offering seemingly competitive products, these sales figures are insufficient to sustain a car company in the long term, especially given the high costs associated with EV development and production.

The Future of the Chinese EV Market

The challenges faced by Yan Hung and other smaller EV manufacturers point to a broader trend in the Chinese automotive industry. Many industry experts predict that numerous bankruptcies will occur in this sector over the next 15 years.

Factors Contributing to Future Bankruptcies

Several factors are likely to accelerate the rate of bankruptcies in the Chinese EV sector:

1. Market saturation: With around 90 EV brands currently operating in China, the market is overcrowded.
2. Shrinking market share: As larger players consolidate their positions, smaller companies are left competing for an increasingly small piece of the market.
3. High costs of EV development: The substantial investment required for EV research, development, and production makes it difficult for smaller companies to compete effectively.
4. Changing consumer preferences: As the EV market matures, consumers may gravitate towards established brands, making it harder for newer or smaller companies to gain traction.

Potential Outcomes for Struggling EV Companies

As the market consolidates, several outcomes are possible for struggling EV manufacturers:

1. Bankruptcy: Some companies will inevitably fail and cease operations.
2. Mergers and acquisitions: Stronger companies may acquire struggling ones to expand their market share or gain access to specific technologies.
3. Government intervention: In some cases, local or national governments may step in to save companies deemed strategically important.
4. Pivot to other industries: Some companies may abandon EV production and refocus their efforts on other automotive-related sectors or entirely different industries.

Lessons for Investors and Industry Observers

The ongoing consolidation in the Chinese EV market offers several important lessons:

1. Caution in "next Tesla" investments: Investors should be wary of claims about finding the "next Tesla." The success of Tesla is unique, and replicating it is extremely challenging.
2. Market size matters: Even in a growing sector like EVs, market size is not infinite. As the market matures, consolidation is inevitable.
3. Brand strength is crucial: Companies with strong brand recognition and customer loyalty are more likely to survive market turbulence.
4. Financial stability is key: Companies need robust financial foundations to weather the ups and downs of the automotive industry, especially in the capital-intensive EV sector.
5. Government policy impacts: Changes in government policies, such as subsidy reductions, can have significant effects on the EV market.

The Global Implications

While this article focuses on the Chinese EV market, the trends observed here have global implications:

1. Supply chain effects: Bankruptcies in China could disrupt global EV supply chains, affecting manufacturers worldwide.
2. Market entry barriers: The challenges faced by Chinese EV startups may deter new entrants in other markets.
3. Consolidation trends: Similar consolidation trends may occur in other regions as their EV markets mature.
4. Technology transfer: As companies go bankrupt or get acquired, their technologies and intellectual property may be redistributed, potentially accelerating EV development globally.

Conclusion

The Chinese EV market is at a critical juncture. The current oversaturation of brands is unsustainable, and a period of significant consolidation appears inevitable. Companies like Yan Hung serve as cautionary tales, illustrating the challenges faced by smaller players in this highly competitive market.

As this consolidation unfolds, it will reshape not only the Chinese automotive landscape but also influence global EV trends. Investors, industry professionals, and policymakers worldwide should closely monitor these developments, as they will likely have far-reaching implications for the future of electric mobility.

The coming years will be crucial in determining which companies emerge as the long-term winners in the EV race. While the road ahead may be bumpy for many current players, the overall trend towards electrification remains strong. The key question is not if the EV revolution will continue, but rather which companies will survive to lead it into the future.

Article created from: https://youtu.be/Dcp60k8kFMs?feature=shared