Biden's Final Medals of Freedom: A Controversial List of Recipients

Biden Awards Final Presidential Medals of Freedom

President Joe Biden recently awarded his final batch of Presidential Medals of Freedom, honoring 18 recipients in a ceremony that has sparked discussion and controversy. The list of honorees includes some notable and polarizing figures, signaling what some see as Biden's support for the political establishment.

Notable Recipients

Some of the high-profile recipients include:

• Hillary Clinton, former Secretary of State and presidential candidate
• George Soros, billionaire investor and philanthropist (accepted by his son Alex)
• Bono, lead singer of U2
• Magic Johnson, basketball legend
• Lionel Messi, soccer superstar (did not attend)
• Bill Nye, science educator
• Denzel Washington, actor
• Anna Wintour, Vogue editor-in-chief

Controversial Choices

The inclusion of certain recipients has drawn criticism and debate:

George Soros: The 94-year-old billionaire was recognized for his efforts to "strengthen democracy, human rights, education and social justice" through his Open Society Foundations. However, Soros is a controversial figure in some circles, with critics accusing him of using his wealth to influence global politics.

Hillary Clinton: The former First Lady, Senator, and Secretary of State remains a divisive figure in American politics. Her selection for the Medal of Freedom has been seen by some as a political statement by the Biden administration.

Establishment Support

Many observers have interpreted Biden's choices as a clear message of support for the political establishment. The New York Times noted that the "recipient list [was] stocked with old-guard icons and political backers" and suggested it was a signal of "support for the establishment his successor wants to tear down."

Notable Absences and Reactions

Lionel Messi: The soccer superstar was named as a recipient but did not attend the ceremony or send a representative to accept the medal on his behalf.

Bono: When the U2 frontman's name was announced, President Biden reportedly gave two fist pumps, possibly acknowledging their shared Irish heritage.

White House Press Secretary's Response

White House Press Secretary Karine Jean-Pierre posted on social media praising her team as "the best in the business," but faced significant backlash in the replies. Critics accused her of covering up for what they perceive as Biden's diminished mental state and misleading the public on various issues.

Analysis of Biden's Medal of Freedom Choices

Political Messaging

The selection of Medal of Freedom recipients is often seen as a way for presidents to send political messages and honor those who align with their values and priorities. In Biden's case, the choices seem to reflect a strong emphasis on established political figures and cultural icons associated with liberal or progressive causes.

Potential Backlash

While the Medal of Freedom is meant to be a non-partisan honor, the inclusion of politically charged figures like Hillary Clinton and George Soros may fuel criticism from Biden's opponents. This could potentially be used as a talking point by rival political camps in the lead-up to future elections.

Cultural Significance

The diverse list of recipients, including figures from sports, entertainment, science, and activism, highlights the broad scope of American achievement and influence. However, it also raises questions about the criteria for selection and whether some choices were made more for their symbolic value than their concrete accomplishments.

International Dimension

The inclusion of international figures like Lionel Messi (though he did not attend) and Bono adds a global dimension to the awards. This could be seen as an effort by the Biden administration to emphasize America's connections to the wider world at a time of increasing isolationist sentiment in some quarters.

Historical Context of the Presidential Medal of Freedom

Origin and Purpose

The Presidential Medal of Freedom was established in 1963 by President John F. Kennedy. It is considered the highest civilian honor in the United States and is awarded to individuals who have made "an especially meritorious contribution to the security or national interests of the United States, world peace, cultural or other significant public or private endeavors."

Evolution of the Award

Over the years, the Medal of Freedom has been awarded to a wide range of individuals, from civil rights leaders and scientists to athletes and entertainers. Each president has put their own stamp on the selection process, often reflecting their personal values and the political climate of their time.

Comparison to Previous Administrations

Biden's choices for the Medal of Freedom can be compared to those of his predecessors:

• Obama Administration: Known for honoring a diverse group of recipients, including many figures from popular culture and sports.
• Trump Administration: Tended to focus more on conservative figures and supporters, including several posthumous awards to historical figures.
• Bush Administration: Balanced between political allies, cultural figures, and international leaders.

Implications for Biden's Legacy

Reinforcing Political Alliances

By honoring figures like Hillary Clinton and George Soros, Biden is reinforcing his ties to the Democratic establishment and signaling continuity with previous Democratic administrations.

Cultural Messaging

The inclusion of popular figures like Denzel Washington and Bill Nye could be seen as an attempt to connect with broader segments of the American public and highlight the importance of science and the arts.

Potential Criticism

The choices may open Biden to criticism from opponents who see the selections as overly partisan or as rewards for political allies rather than recognition of genuine merit.

Public Reception and Media Coverage

Mixed Reactions

Public reaction to the Medal of Freedom recipients has been mixed, with supporters praising the diverse list of accomplished individuals and critics questioning the inclusion of certain controversial figures.

Media Framing

Mainstream media outlets have largely reported on the awards ceremony in a straightforward manner, though some have noted the political implications of Biden's choices. Conservative media sources have been more critical, particularly of recipients like Clinton and Soros.

Social Media Response

On social media platforms, reactions have been polarized, with supporters and critics of the Biden administration using the awards as fodder for ongoing political debates.

Conclusion

President Biden's final round of Presidential Medal of Freedom awards has generated significant discussion and controversy. The choices reflect a clear alignment with established political and cultural figures associated with liberal causes, potentially reinforcing Biden's image as a defender of the status quo in the face of populist challenges.

While the diverse list of recipients highlights American achievement across various fields, the inclusion of polarizing figures may detract from the non-partisan spirit of the award. As Biden's presidency enters its final stages, these awards will likely be remembered as a statement of his values and priorities, for better or worse.

Ultimately, the true impact of these Medal of Freedom selections will be determined by how they are perceived by the American public and how they fit into the broader narrative of Biden's presidency. As with many aspects of his administration, these choices are likely to be debated and scrutinized long after the medals have been awarded.

Article created from: https://youtu.be/A-Ki2R7JniA?feature=shared