Anime Goat Talk: Crowning the Greatest in Every Category

The Ultimate Anime Showdown Begins

Anime fans, assemble! It's time for the most epic debate in otaku history - crowning the greatest of all time (GOAT) across multiple anime categories. At Momocon 2024, a panel of up to 30 judges came together to settle some of the most heated debates in anime fandom once and for all. Through a series of rounds with majority votes determining the winners, we're about to find out which series, characters, and moments truly stand above the rest.

Best Anime Film: Perfect Blue Takes the Crown

Kicking things off with a bang, the category of best anime film sparked immediate controversy. While some judges initially suggested mainstream hits, the psychological thriller Perfect Blue emerged victorious. Directed by the legendary Satoshi Kon, Perfect Blue is widely regarded as a masterpiece of psychological horror.

For those unfamiliar with the film, Perfect Blue follows Mima Kirigoe, a pop idol who decides to pursue an acting career. As she takes on more mature roles, her grip on reality begins to slip, blurring the lines between her public persona and true self. The film's exploration of identity, fame, and the dark side of the entertainment industry resonated strongly with the judges.

Some key factors that likely contributed to Perfect Blue's win:

• Groundbreaking animation and cinematography for its time
• Complex, multilayered plot that rewards multiple viewings
• Psychological depth rarely seen in animated films
• Influence on later directors like Darren Aronofsky

While some judges admitted to not having seen the film, its reputation alone was enough to secure the win. For anime fans who haven't experienced Perfect Blue yet, the judges strongly recommended watching it - with the caveat that it may leave you "mentally messed up."

Best Anime Opening: Chainsaw Man's "Kick Back" Revs Up

Moving on to openings, the competition was fierce. Anime openings play a crucial role in setting the tone for a series and getting viewers hyped. After much debate, Chainsaw Man's opening "Kick Back" by Kenshi Yonezu claimed the top spot.

"Kick Back" took the internet by storm when Chainsaw Man premiered, dominating discussions for months. The opening's frenetic energy, stunning visuals, and catchy tune perfectly capture the chaotic spirit of the series. Some standout elements include:

• Dynamic action sequences showcasing the main characters
• Clever visual metaphors and foreshadowing
• Seamless blend of 2D and 3D animation
• Kenshi Yonezu's infectious vocals and lyrics

The judges noted how "Kick Back" elevated the already high expectations for Chainsaw Man, proving that a great opening can significantly boost a show's popularity and impact.

Best Protagonist: Guts from Berserk Cuts Through the Competition

When it came time to crown the greatest anime protagonist, one name stood above all others - Guts from Berserk. The Black Swordsman's victory was nearly unanimous, with judges rushing to show their support.

Guts' appeal as a protagonist stems from several factors:

• Tragic backstory that shapes his character
• Unbreakable will and determination
• Complex relationships with allies and enemies
• Brutal combat skills balanced with moments of vulnerability
• Character growth and development throughout the series

The judges praised Guts as a multifaceted character who transcends the typical shonen hero archetype. His journey from lone wolf to reluctant leader resonates with fans, while his struggles against fate and inner demons add depth to his character.

Berserk creator Kentaro Miura's masterful storytelling and artwork bring Guts to life in a way few other protagonists can match. Even those unfamiliar with Berserk recognized Guts' iconic status in the anime community.

Most Attractive Character: Yor Forger Assassinates the Competition

In a surprising twist, the category for most attractive character caused quite a stir. While many expected a more established character to take the crown, Yor Forger from the recent hit Spy x Family emerged victorious.

Yor's appeal stems from several factors:

• Striking character design with her long dark hair and red eyes
• Contrast between her elegant appearance and deadly assassin skills
• Endearing personality as she navigates family life
• Balance of strength and vulnerability

The judges noted how Yor's popularity exploded almost immediately after Spy x Family's premiere. Her combination of beauty, skill, and charm won over fans across demographics.

While some argued for more established characters like Gojo from Jujutsu Kaisen, Yor's victory highlights the impact newer series can have on the anime landscape. It also speaks to the growing popularity of characters who subvert traditional gender roles and expectations.

Greatest Anime of All Time: The One Piece Debate Rages On

Perhaps the most contentious category of all - the greatest anime of all time. As expected, One Piece emerged as a frontrunner, with passionate fans arguing for its unparalleled world-building and character development. However, the competition was fierce, with classics like Fullmetal Alchemist and JoJo's Bizarre Adventure also receiving strong support.

Arguments in favor of One Piece included:

• Massive, intricately crafted world
• Huge cast of memorable characters
• Consistent quality over its long run
• Themes of friendship, dreams, and freedom
• Impact on the anime industry and pop culture

Detractors pointed to the series' intimidating length and slow pacing at times. Other contenders like Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood were praised for their tighter storytelling and thematic depth.

Ultimately, the category ended in a heated debate with no clear consensus. This speaks to the diversity of the anime medium and the personal connection fans form with their favorite series. The lack of agreement also highlights how difficult it is to objectively crown a single "greatest" anime when the medium spans so many genres and styles.

Best Antagonist: Meruem's Evolution Conquers All

When it came to choosing the greatest antagonist in anime history, one character stood head and shoulders above the rest - Meruem from Hunter x Hunter. The Chimera Ant King's complex character arc and philosophical depth earned him near-unanimous praise from the judges.

What makes Meruem such a compelling antagonist:

• Starts as a seemingly one-dimensional villain but evolves dramatically
• Challenges the protagonists physically and ideologically
• Relationship with Komugi adds unexpected depth to his character
• Forces viewers to question the nature of humanity
• Subverts typical shonen antagonist tropes

The judges highlighted how Meruem's character development over the course of the Chimera Ant arc elevates him beyond a simple villain. His journey from a being of pure strength to one capable of compassion and self-reflection resonated strongly with fans.

While other antagonists like Light Yagami from Death Note received some support, Meruem's victory was decisive. His impact on the Hunter x Hunter story and the broader anime landscape secured his place as the GOAT antagonist.

Best Power System: Nen from Hunter x Hunter Flexes its Strength

Another category that saw Hunter x Hunter claim victory was best power system, with the series' Nen abilities taking the top spot. The judges praised Nen for its complexity, versatility, and integration into the world of Hunter x Hunter.

What sets Nen apart from other anime power systems:

• Logical rules and limitations that create strategic battles
• Personalized abilities that reflect characters' personalities
• Multiple categories and applications (Enhancement, Transmutation, etc.)
• Potential for creative uses and combinations
• Seamless integration into the story and world-building

The judges noted how Nen avoids many of the pitfalls of typical shonen power systems, where abilities often become overpowered or inconsistent. Instead, Nen's clearly defined rules and limitations create tension and strategy in fights.

While other systems like Jujutsu Kaisen's Cursed Energy received praise, Nen's depth and impact on its series gave it the edge. The fact that fans still analyze and discuss Nen years after Hunter x Hunter's hiatus speaks to its lasting appeal.

Best Mentor: Kakashi Hatake Teaches a Lesson in Leadership

When it came to crowning the greatest mentor in anime history, one ninja stood above the rest - Kakashi Hatake from Naruto. The Copy Ninja's blend of strength, wisdom, and personal growth resonated strongly with the judges.

What makes Kakashi an exemplary mentor:

• Balances nurturing his students with pushing them to improve
• Leads by example, demonstrating the ninja way through his actions
• Has his own character arc and growth throughout the series
• Adapts his teaching style to each student's needs
• Provides emotional support and guidance beyond just combat training

The judges praised Kakashi's role in shaping the main characters of Naruto, particularly his influence on Naruto, Sasuke, and Sakura. His own backstory and development add depth to his mentor role, showing how he learned from past mistakes to become a better leader.

While other mentors like All Might from My Hero Academia received consideration, Kakashi's long-standing impact on one of anime's most popular franchises secured his victory. His iconic look and catchphrases have become synonymous with the idea of a cool, competent mentor figure.

Best Swordsman: Roronoa Zoro Cuts Down the Competition

In the realm of anime swordsmen, one pirate reigned supreme - Roronoa Zoro from One Piece. The three-sword-wielding first mate of the Straw Hat Pirates sliced through the competition with ease.

What elevates Zoro above other anime swordsmen:

• Unique three-sword style that pushes the boundaries of swordsmanship
• Unwavering determination and loyalty to his crew and dreams
• Constant growth and development of new techniques
• Badass design with his green hair and scarred eye
• Memorable battles against powerful opponents

The judges noted how Zoro's skills go beyond just swordsmanship, encompassing his overall strength of character and role within the Straw Hat crew. His dream of becoming the world's greatest swordsman drives him to constantly improve and overcome seemingly impossible odds.

While other skilled swordsmen like Kenshin Himura from Rurouni Kenshin received praise, Zoro's iconic status and continued relevance in one of anime's longest-running series gave him the edge. The fact that he can go toe-to-toe with some of One Piece's strongest characters using pure skill (and only one eye!) cements his place as the GOAT swordsman.

Best Female Lead: Tohru Honda's Kindness Conquers All

When it came to crowning the greatest female lead in anime, one name rose above the rest - Tohru Honda from Fruits Basket. The kindhearted protagonist's impact on both her fellow characters and the audience earned her a decisive victory.

What makes Tohru such a beloved female lead:

• Unwavering kindness and optimism in the face of adversity
• Growth from a naive girl to a strong, compassionate young woman
• Ability to connect with and heal the troubled Sohma family
• Relatable struggles with loss, self-worth, and finding her place
• Subversion of typical shoujo heroine tropes

The judges praised Tohru's role in driving the emotional core of Fruits Basket. Her journey of self-discovery and impact on those around her resonated strongly with fans. While some argued that Tohru's kindness could come across as unrealistic, the majority felt that her character depth and growth throughout the series justified her status as a top-tier female lead.

Other contenders like Violet Evergarden received consideration, but Tohru's victory speaks to the enduring appeal of Fruits Basket and its central heroine. Her ability to tackle heavy themes with grace and optimism sets her apart in the world of anime protagonists.

Best World-Building: One Piece Creates a Grand Line of Adventure

When it came to the anime with the most immersive and well-crafted world, One Piece sailed away with an overwhelming victory. Eiichiro Oda's epic pirate saga has spent over two decades expanding its vast and intricate world, captivating fans with its depth and creativity.

What sets One Piece's world-building apart:

• Massive scale encompassing numerous islands and cultures
• Rich history that continues to unfold and impact the present
• Diverse cast of characters with unique backgrounds and motivations
• Intricate power structures and political intrigue
• Seamless blend of fantasy elements with recognizable themes

The judges praised how One Piece's world feels alive and ever-expanding. Each new island introduces unique cultures, creatures, and conflicts that tie into the broader narrative. The series' ability to maintain consistent internal logic while constantly introducing new elements is a testament to Oda's skill as a storyteller.

While other series like Attack on Titan and Made in Abyss received praise for their world-building, One Piece's sheer scale and attention to detail gave it the edge. The fact that fans can still theorize and discover new connections after 1000+ chapters speaks to the depth of its world.

Best Tournament Arc: Yu Yu Hakusho's Dark Tournament Reigns Supreme

When it came to crowning the greatest tournament arc in anime history, one series stood above the rest - Yu Yu Hakusho's legendary Dark Tournament. This arc set the standard for shonen tournament arcs and continues to be celebrated decades later.

What makes the Dark Tournament arc so iconic:

• High stakes with life-or-death battles
• Character development for both heroes and villains
• Diverse range of opponents with unique abilities
• Emotional weight tied to Genkai's storyline
• Culminates in an epic showdown with Toguro

The judges praised how the Dark Tournament balances intense action with character growth and emotional storytelling. Each fight feels meaningful, advancing both the plot and the characters' personal journeys. The arc's pacing keeps viewers on the edge of their seats while still allowing for quieter character moments.

While other tournament arcs like the Chunin Exams from Naruto received strong consideration, the Dark Tournament's lasting impact on the genre secured its victory. Its influence can be seen in countless later series, cementing its place as the gold standard for anime tournaments.

Best Ending: Code Geass Sticks the Landing

Delivering a satisfying conclusion to a beloved series is no easy task, but Code Geass managed to pull it off in spectacular fashion. The mecha series' ending was voted the best in anime, praised for its emotional impact and thematic resonance.

What makes Code Geass' ending stand out:

• Brings the complex plot threads together cohesively
• Delivers emotional payoff for character arcs
• Subverts expectations while staying true to the series' themes
• Leaves a lasting impact on viewers
• Sparks discussion and analysis years later

The judges noted how Code Geass' ending manages to be both surprising and inevitable, tying together the series' exploration of morality, sacrifice, and the nature of peace. Without spoiling specifics, the conclusion forces viewers to grapple with complex ethical questions while delivering an emotionally satisfying resolution.

While other series like Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood received praise for their endings, Code Geass' ability to stick such a difficult landing gave it the edge. The fact that fans still debate and analyze the ending years later speaks to its lasting impact.

Conclusion: The Endless Debate Continues

As our anime GOAT talk comes to a close, it's clear that the world of anime is as diverse and passionate as ever. While we've crowned winners in various categories, the debates are far from settled. The beauty of anime lies in its ability to resonate with viewers in deeply personal ways, making definitive "best of" lists nearly impossible.

What we can say for certain is that the medium continues to evolve and push boundaries. From psychological thrillers like Perfect Blue to long-running epics like One Piece, anime offers something for every taste. New series like Chainsaw Man and Spy x Family prove that fresh voices can still make a huge impact, while classics like Yu Yu Hakusho and Code Geass maintain their legendary status years later.

As fans, we're fortunate to have such a rich tapestry of stories, characters, and worlds to explore. Whether you agree with the judges' choices or have your own picks, there's no denying the passion and creativity that anime inspires. So let's celebrate the medium in all its forms - from the universally acclaimed masterpieces to the hidden gems waiting to be discovered.

The debate over the greatest anime will likely rage on for years to come, and that's exactly how it should be. After all, it's through these discussions that we deepen our appreciation for the artform and connect with fellow fans. So keep watching, keep discussing, and keep spreading the love for anime in all its weird and wonderful glory.

Article created from: https://youtu.be/Xj0t2-6wvI4?feature=shared