Analyzing Real People's Finances: Income, Debt, and Spending Habits

In this article, we'll take a deep dive into the finances of three different households, analyzing their income, debt, spending habits, and investment strategies. We'll look at their current financial situations and provide recommendations for improvement.

Case Study 1: Single Parent Teacher in Denver

Background

• Name: Casey
• Age: 30
• Location: Denver, Colorado
• Occupation: Middle School Teacher
• Family: Single parent with one child

Financial Overview

• Assets: $28,000
• Investments: $37,000
• Savings: $14,000
• Debt: $57,000
• Net Worth: $22,000
• Monthly Income: $6,000 ($72,000 annually)

Spending Breakdown

• Fixed Costs: 47% of income
• Housing (rent + utilities): 19% of income
• Investments: 7% of income
• Savings: 4% of income
• Guilt-free spending: 42% of income

Analysis and Recommendations

Impressive Fixed Costs Management

Casey's fixed costs at 47% of income are remarkably low, especially considering she lives in Denver, which is not a cheap city. This demonstrates excellent financial discipline and living below her means.

Investment and Savings

While Casey is investing 7% of her income, which falls within the recommended 5-10% range, there's room for improvement. Given her age and income level, increasing this percentage over time could significantly impact her long-term financial health. A strategy of increasing the investment percentage by 1% each year during her annual financial review could yield substantial returns over her lifetime.

The savings rate of 4% is below the recommended minimum of 5%. However, Casey has managed to build a 6-month emergency fund, which is commendable. Given the relatively small absolute value of her emergency fund ($14,000), increasing this buffer would provide more financial stability.

Home Ownership Aspirations

Casey expressed a desire to buy a house, but her current financial situation doesn't support this goal in the near term. The median sale price for a house in Denver is $580,000, requiring a down payment of $116,000 for a 20% down payment or $58,000 for a 10% down payment. With only $14,000 in savings and no dedicated savings for a down payment, this goal is not currently feasible.

Retirement Projections

Based on current investment rates, Casey is projected to have $997,000 by age 65. Using the 4% safe withdrawal rule, this would provide an annual income of $39,880 in retirement. While this is a substantial sum, it may not be sufficient to maintain her current lifestyle, especially considering potential increases in living costs.

Recommendations

1. Redirect college fund contributions: By investing the $100 currently going to her child's college fund into her own retirement account, Casey could increase her retirement savings to $1.1 million, an additional $170,000.

2. Reduce guilt-free spending: Cutting $500 from the current $2,151 guilt-free spending and investing it could increase retirement savings to $2 million, providing $80,000 annual safe withdrawal in retirement.

3. Reassess home ownership goals: Given the current financial situation, Casey should consider delaying or adjusting her home ownership goals. Renting may be a more financially prudent option in the near term.

4. Increase income: Exploring opportunities to increase income, either through career advancement in education or side gigs, could provide more flexibility in achieving financial goals.

5. Focus on retirement savings: Prioritize increasing retirement savings to ensure long-term financial security.

Case Study 2: Married Couple with Young Children in Michigan

Background

• Names: Emily (35) and Steve (40)
• Location: Michigan, 20 minutes outside Detroit
• Occupations: Emily is a stay-at-home mom, Steve is a lab supervisor
• Family: Married with two children (ages 3 years and 10 months)

Financial Overview

• Assets: $350,000
• Investments: $190,000
• Savings: $9,000
• Debt: $35,000
• Net Worth: $514,000
• Monthly Income: $9,000 ($108,000 annually)

Spending Breakdown

• Fixed Costs: 67% of income
• Housing (mortgage + utilities): 9% of income
• Investments: 10% of income
• Savings: 3% of income
• Guilt-free spending: 16% of income

Analysis and Recommendations

Impressive Investment Portfolio

Emily and Steve have managed to accumulate a substantial investment portfolio of $190,000, which is commendable given their income level and family situation. This demonstrates a strong commitment to long-term financial planning.

High Fixed Costs

Their fixed costs at 67% of income are concerningly high. While this includes necessary expenses like groceries and diapers for young children, it leaves little room for financial flexibility. Reducing this percentage to 60% or below would provide more financial stability.

Low Housing Costs

Their housing costs at 9% of income are impressively low, especially considering they live near Detroit. This smart housing decision allows for more financial flexibility in other areas.

Emergency Fund

With only 3 months of emergency savings, the family is in a potentially risky position, especially as a single-income household with young children. Increasing this to at least 6 months of expenses should be a priority.

Retirement Projections

Based on current investment rates, Emily and Steve are projected to have $1.3 million by retirement age. This would provide an annual safe withdrawal of $54,000, which is only half of their current income. This significant drop in income could be stressful and may not be sufficient to maintain their desired lifestyle in retirement.

Recommendations

1. Increase emergency fund: Prioritize building the emergency fund to at least 6 months of expenses to provide more financial security for the single-income family.

2. Reduce miscellaneous expenses: The $368 allocated to miscellaneous expenses could be reduced to provide more room in the budget for savings and investments.

3. Increase income: Explore opportunities for Steve to negotiate a raise or for Emily to take on part-time work or freelance opportunities when feasible.

4. Reassess travel goals: While travel is important to the family, it may need to be temporarily scaled back to focus on building financial security.

5. Plan for Emily's return to work: Develop a clear plan for when Emily plans to return to work and how this will impact their financial situation and goals.

6. Increase retirement savings: As their financial situation allows, aim to increase retirement savings to ensure a more comfortable retirement income.

Case Study 3: Married Couple without Children in North Idaho

Background

• Names: G (37) and N (38)
• Location: North Idaho
• Occupations: G is a grants coordinator, N is an elementary school teacher
• Family: Married, no children

Financial Overview

• Assets: $420,000
• Investments: $277,000
• Savings: $227,000
• Debt: $196,000 (house and two car loans)
• Net Worth: $727,000
• Monthly Income: $10,532 ($126,000 annually)

Spending Breakdown

• Fixed Costs: 67% of income (reduced to 61% after analysis)
• Housing: 16% of income
• Investments: 14% of income
• Savings: 1% of income
• Guilt-free spending: 24% of income

Analysis and Recommendations

Strong Net Worth

With a net worth of $727,000 at ages 37 and 38, G and N have built a solid financial foundation. Their investment portfolio of $277,000 and savings of $227,000 demonstrate a strong commitment to financial security.

High Fixed Costs

Their fixed costs at 67% of income are high, but this includes a significant $2,000 monthly allocation for miscellaneous expenses. Reducing this to a more reasonable $500 brings their fixed costs down to a more manageable 61%.

Impressive Investment Rate

Investing 14% of their income is commendable and above the recommended minimum. This aggressive saving strategy in their 30s sets them up for significant financial growth in the future.

Excess Cash Savings

With $227,000 in savings, G and N have more than enough for an emergency fund. Some of this money could be redirected to investments for potentially higher returns.

Retirement Projections

Based on current investment rates, G and N are projected to have $3 million by retirement age. This would provide an annual safe withdrawal of $120,000, which is close to their current income and should allow for a comfortable retirement.

Recommendations

1. Reallocate savings: Consider moving $50,000 to $100,000 from savings to investments. This could increase their retirement savings to $3.3 million or $3.6 million respectively.

2. Reduce miscellaneous spending: Cut down the $2,000 monthly miscellaneous allocation to a more reasonable amount, freeing up money for other financial goals.

3. Explore real estate investments: If interested in real estate, consider using some of the excess savings for a down payment on investment properties.

4. Increase financial collaboration: Ensure both partners are involved in financial decision-making and understand their investments and overall financial strategy.

5. Define rich life goals: Have serious conversations about what constitutes a rich life for both partners. This could involve increased travel, dining out more, or other lifestyle enhancements.

6. Consider individual guilt-free spending: Allocate some of the guilt-free spending budget for individual use by each partner.

7. Use a financial journal: Consider using a financial journal to help clarify financial goals and aspirations.

In conclusion, these case studies demonstrate the importance of tailoring financial advice to individual circumstances. While general principles of saving, investing, and managing debt apply broadly, the specific strategies and priorities can vary greatly depending on factors such as income, family situation, location, and personal goals. Regular financial reviews, open communication about money, and a clear vision of one's "rich life" are crucial for long-term financial success and satisfaction.

Article created from: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cVC3WtVZD08