1911 vs 2011 Pistols: Key Differences and Advantages

The Legacy of the 1911 and the Rise of the 2011

The world of handguns has seen significant evolution over the years, with two notable designs standing out: the classic 1911 and its modern counterpart, the 2011. Both pistols have their merits and dedicated followings, but what sets them apart? Let's dive into the key differences between these two iconic firearms.

Understanding the 1911

The 1911 pistol, designed by the legendary John Moses Browning, has been a staple in the firearms world for over a century. Its longevity is a testament to its reliable design and performance.

Key Features of the 1911

• Single Action: The 1911 is a single-action pistol, meaning the trigger only releases the hammer. This results in a crisp, light trigger pull that many shooters appreciate.

• Manual Operation: Users must manually rack the slide to load the first round and cock the hammer.

• Single Stack Magazine: Traditionally, 1911s use a single stack magazine, typically holding 7-8 rounds.

• Caliber: Originally designed for .45 ACP, modern variants are available in various calibers, including 9mm and .38 Super.

• Thin Profile: The single stack magazine allows for a thin grip, which some shooters find more comfortable.

The 1911's Enduring Appeal

Despite being over a century old, the 1911 remains popular for several reasons:

1. Historical Significance: Its use in two world wars has cemented its place in military history.

2. Excellent Trigger: The 1911 is renowned for its crisp, light trigger pull.

3. Accuracy: Many shooters find the 1911 to be inherently accurate.

4. Customization: There's a vast aftermarket for 1911 parts and accessories.

5. Thin Profile: Some shooters prefer the thinner grip for concealed carry.

Introducing the 2011

The 2011 is essentially a modernized, double-stack version of the 1911. It retains many of the 1911's beloved features while addressing some of its limitations.

Key Features of the 2011

• Double Stack Magazine: The most significant difference is the higher capacity magazine, often holding 20+ rounds.

• Modular Design: Many 2011s feature a removable grip module, allowing for customization.

• Optics Ready: Most 2011s come with slides cut for mounting red dot sights.

• Wider Grip: The double-stack magazine necessitates a wider grip, which some shooters find more comfortable.

• Modern Materials: 2011s often incorporate polymer and other modern materials in their construction.

Advantages of the 2011

1. Higher Capacity: The double-stack magazine significantly increases round count.

2. Modularity: The ability to swap grip modules offers versatility.

3. Modern Features: Optics cuts and accessory rails are standard on most 2011s.

4. Reduced Recoil: The added weight can help mitigate recoil.

5. Competition Ready: Many 2011s are designed with competitive shooting in mind.

Comparing 1911 and 2011: A Closer Look

Frame and Grip

The most noticeable difference between the 1911 and 2011 is the grip width. The 1911's single-stack magazine allows for a thin profile, while the 2011's double-stack magazine requires a wider grip.

1911:

• Thinner grip
• Single-piece frame
• Traditional wood or polymer grips

2011:

• Wider grip
• Often features a separate grip module
• Typically polymer grip with texture for enhanced hold

Magazine Capacity

One of the primary advantages of the 2011 over the 1911 is its increased magazine capacity.

1911:

• Typically 7-8 rounds in .45 ACP
• Up to 10 rounds in 9mm

2011:

• Often 20+ rounds in 9mm
• 16+ rounds in .45 ACP

Trigger Mechanism

Both the 1911 and 2011 use a single-action trigger mechanism, known for its crisp break and short reset.

1911:

• Narrow trigger due to single-stack frame
• Often features a solid trigger

2011:

• Wider trigger to accommodate double-stack magazine
• May feature a skeletonized trigger for weight reduction

Slide Design

The slide designs of the 1911 and 2011 are remarkably similar, with a few key differences.

1911:

• Traditional design
• May or may not have an optics cut (depends on manufacturer)

2011:

• Often comes optics-ready from the factory
• May feature lightening cuts for reduced reciprocating mass

Weight and Balance

The weight and balance of these pistols can vary significantly based on materials and specific models.

1911:

• Typically all-steel construction
• Weight varies but often around 35-40 oz unloaded

2011:

• May incorporate polymer components for weight reduction
• Weight can vary widely, but often slightly heavier than a 1911 due to larger size

Customization and Aftermarket Support

Both platforms enjoy extensive aftermarket support, but there are some differences.

1911:

• Vast array of aftermarket parts available
• Long history of customization options

2011:

• Growing aftermarket support
• Some parts interchangeable with 1911, others proprietary

Choosing Between 1911 and 2011

Deciding between a 1911 and a 2011 comes down to personal preference and intended use. Here are some factors to consider:

Hand Size and Comfort

If you have smaller hands, you might find the thinner grip of the 1911 more comfortable. Conversely, those with larger hands may prefer the fuller grip of the 2011.

Intended Use

• Concealed Carry: The thinner profile of the 1911 may be advantageous for concealment.
• Home Defense: The higher capacity of the 2011 could be beneficial in a home defense scenario.
• Competition: Many competitive shooters prefer the 2011 for its higher capacity and modern features.
• Collecting: For those interested in historical firearms, the 1911 holds significant appeal.

Budget

1911s are available at a wide range of price points, from budget-friendly to high-end custom models. 2011s tend to be more expensive on average, with fewer budget options available.

Shooting Experience

Both pistols offer excellent shooting experiences, but there are subtle differences:

• The 1911's thinner grip and potentially lighter weight may result in more felt recoil.
• The 2011's added weight and wider grip can help mitigate recoil, especially in 9mm models.

Maintenance and Parts Availability

1911s have been around for over a century, meaning parts and gunsmithing expertise are widely available. While 2011 parts are becoming more common, they may not be as readily available as 1911 parts.

Popular Manufacturers

1911 Manufacturers

1. Colt
2. Springfield Armory
3. Kimber
4. Smith & Wesson
5. Ruger
6. Dan Wesson
7. Wilson Combat
8. Nighthawk Custom

2011 Manufacturers

1. Staccato (formerly STI)
2. Springfield Armory (Prodigy)
3. Wilson Combat
4. Nighthawk Custom
5. Atlas Gunworks
6. Bul Armory
7. Rock Island Armory (some models)

Caliber Options

Both 1911s and 2011s are available in various calibers, each offering different characteristics:

Common 1911 Calibers

1. .45 ACP: The original 1911 caliber, known for its stopping power.
2. 9mm: Offers higher capacity and lower recoil.
3. .38 Super: Popular in competition for its flat trajectory and major power factor.
4. 10mm: Provides high energy for hunting or self-defense.
5. .22 LR: Available in some models for training or plinking.

Common 2011 Calibers

1. 9mm: The most popular caliber for 2011s, offering high capacity and manageable recoil.
2. .45 ACP: Available in some models for those who prefer the larger caliber.
3. .40 S&W: Offers a balance between 9mm and .45 ACP.

Training and Skill Development

Both the 1911 and 2011 platforms can be excellent tools for developing shooting skills:

1911 for Skill Development

• The thin profile can help reinforce proper grip technique.
• Lower capacity encourages focus on accuracy and shot placement.
• Manual safety and grip safety promote good safety habits.

2011 for Skill Development

• Higher capacity allows for longer strings of fire in training.
• Often easier to shoot well due to reduced recoil and fuller grip.
• Modern features like optics cuts can help in learning red dot use.

Competitive Shooting

Both 1911s and 2011s have their place in competitive shooting:

1911 in Competition

• Popular in divisions that require single-stack magazines.
• Often seen in "Classic" or "Single Stack" divisions.
• .45 ACP 1911s are common in "Major" power factor divisions.

2011 in Competition

• Dominant in "Open" and "Limited" divisions.
• Higher capacity is advantageous in courses of fire with many targets.
• Often customized with compensators, red dot sights, and other performance-enhancing features.

Collectibility and Investment

Firearms can sometimes be considered from an investment or collectibility standpoint:

1911 Collectibility

• Historical models, especially military-issue pistols, can be highly collectible.
• Some limited edition or commemorative 1911s appreciate in value.
• Certain manufacturers like Singer (known for sewing machines) produced 1911s during WWII, which are now rare and valuable.

2011 Collectibility

• As a newer platform, 2011s haven't developed the same collector's market as 1911s.
• However, some limited run models from high-end manufacturers may appreciate in value.
• The collectibility of 2011s may increase as the platform ages and certain models become discontinued.

Conclusion

The choice between a 1911 and a 2011 ultimately comes down to personal preference, intended use, and individual needs. The 1911 continues to be a beloved classic, appreciated for its history, slim profile, and excellent trigger. The 2011, on the other hand, offers increased capacity, modern features, and potentially softer shooting characteristics.

Both platforms have their strengths and devoted followings. For those who appreciate the classic design and handling of the 1911 but want increased capacity and modern features, the 2011 offers an excellent compromise. Conversely, purists and those who prioritize a thin profile may prefer to stick with the time-tested 1911.

Regardless of which platform you choose, both the 1911 and 2011 offer excellent performance, accuracy, and shooting enjoyment. The best way to determine which is right for you is to handle and shoot both, paying attention to which feels more natural and comfortable in your hands.

Remember, the most important factor is not the tool itself, but the skill of the person wielding it. Whether you choose a 1911 or a 2011, regular practice and training will be key to mastering your chosen platform.

Article created from: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aPfTvA6f3h8